The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Julia]

I got two questions, to which side is it unfair and what needs to be added to this side?

Any help is highly appreciated since I have been doing monthly swaps and trades only for the past two years. 8D

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Hcas8dm0dA

Thanks in advance. :3

[JayJennyJane]

Got an answer, thanks

[KaraBear]

I am curious, I hope i did the correct thing. I just offered up two of my very rare rats for trade for event pets. I refused as i know they had several i needed but they refused to add those ones to the trade. Was i right in doing this?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=37638608&userid=364029&signature=WlY4gxdOfjM-IOJvIdx6UQ

What exactly are my Rats worth, Im not a huge fan of rats and i just want something that would be fair.

Extremely unfair to you.

[featherbrownie]

Please help if you can! They say they are overpaying (or maybe they are saying I'm overpaying, I don't know, they just said it was an overpay) but I don't understand how much the zebra is really worth.

Here is the trade:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... _8VI0miLbw

Just a quick note in case you weren't aware: The VR 2009 Bluestar there is actually a rerelease from '08, making it older than the zebra, but I don't know the zebra's true worth. And I'm kind of attached to my warriors and event pets (which will probably all be rare)

[featherbrownie]

I am curious, I hope i did the correct thing. I just offered up two of my very rare rats for trade for event pets. I refused as i know they had several i needed but they refused to add those ones to the trade. Was i right in doing this?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=37638608&userid=364029&signature=WlY4gxdOfjM-IOJvIdx6UQ

What exactly are my Rats worth, Im not a huge fan of rats and i just want something that would be fair.

Extremely unfair to you.

Yes this is unfair to you, because the event pets will probably only turn out rare.

[Ashki]

I am curious, I hope i did the correct thing. I just offered up two of my very rare rats for trade for event pets. I refused as i know they had several i needed but they refused to add those ones to the trade. Was i right in doing this?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=37638608&userid=364029&signature=WlY4gxdOfjM-IOJvIdx6UQ

What exactly are my Rats worth, Im not a huge fan of rats and i just want something that would be fair.

Extremely unfair to you.

Yes this is unfair to you, because the event pets will probably only turn out rare.

They'll likely turn out uncommon, actually. But yes, very unfair to you.

[DuckGoesRawr]

Please help if you can! They say they are overpaying (or maybe they are saying I'm overpaying, I don't know, they just said it was an overpay) but I don't understand how much the zebra is really worth.

Here is the trade:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... _8VI0miLbw

Just a quick note in case you weren't aware: The VR 2009 Bluestar there is actually a rerelease from '08, making it older than the zebra, but I don't know the zebra's true worth. And I'm kind of attached to my warriors and event pets (which will probably all be rare)

It's unfair to you, Bluestar alone would be fair ^^ Also, your warriors are not re releases, they're extended releases, meaning they are worth less than the original adoption date suggests. That set of warriors was available until mid '09 making then only worth around a mid-late '09. I suggest you don't try telling us what a pet is worth if you simply don't know, which is quite obvious, especially when it comes to extended releases ^^

Edit: To add, re-releases only occur from the Dec 18th box (or 24th for '11).

[Icγ]

Um... am I missing something or did this turn into a trade thread? o.o

[mistywater]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=37636223&userid=371883&signature=sNM2Yodia5iVCLgR3-jrh

Is this fair?

[sweet tooth]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=37636223&userid=371883&signature=sNM2Yodia5iVCLgR3-jrh

Is this fair?

Wrong link- please click the "share " box and copy that link