The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Ilovesmoothies!]

Hi, just wondering if this trade is fair > http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 6YWp7wejpw If not what needs to be added/removed? Thanks in advance

[DuckGoesRawr]

A bid like this and this bid, what should I rate them both? :0 They're from different people though, and would they be fair?

Thank you!

The second one is overpay, as the Celestial PPS is a good two tiers above the patchwork dog. The first one is good because of the shima long tail - which is in ridiculous demand - but I can't see any list pets there (correct me if I'm wrong) so it is unfair to you. I personally would accept the one with the celestial PPS. You could ask a second opinion though.

Agreed. The Celestial PPS is overpay and has decent demand, even though the Shima has high demand, it is unfair to you rarity wise. I would personally accept the Celestial out of the two. As for ratings, I'd give the Shima bid a 2/10 rating, maybe a 5/10 with demand. I'd give the Celestial a 10/10 or higher as it is overpay, though it's your choice of what you rate them at, this is just my personal opinion ^^

[Kat]

Is this trade fair?
I don't really know how much the Egypt pets are going for...

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Rncu4IN-og

Thanks in advance! :)

[little sunshine]

A bid like this and this bid, what should I rate them both? :0 They're from different people though, and would they be fair?

Thank you!

The second one is overpay, as the Celestial PPS is a good two tiers above the patchwork dog. The first one is good because of the shima long tail - which is in ridiculous demand - but I can't see any list pets there (correct me if I'm wrong) so it is unfair to you. I personally would accept the one with the celestial PPS. You could ask a second opinion though.

The first one, I think is fair. As the cat is an 09 re release. They might need to add an 09 rare.

[DuckGoesRawr]

Is this trade fair?
I don't really know how much the Egypt pets are going for...

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Rncu4IN-og

Thanks in advance!

Even if the event pets turn rare, I'm certain it'll still be unfair to the '09 very rare. Get another opinion though ^^

[grizzegrijn]

Was this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... TY2IDdVOOw
unfair to you.

I thought so... by how much?

[foresti]

A bid like this and this bid, what should I rate them both? :0 They're from different people though, and would they be fair?

Thank you!

The second one is overpay, as the Celestial PPS is a good two tiers above the patchwork dog. The first one is good because of the shima long tail - which is in ridiculous demand - but I can't see any list pets there (correct me if I'm wrong) so it is unfair to you. I personally would accept the one with the celestial PPS. You could ask a second opinion though.

The second one, I think is fair. As the cat is an 09 re release. They might need to add an 09 rare.

Thank you guys!

[Rune.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=37531927&userid=193170&signature=GEa1TdgKCsHf1FGqw_4PPA
I'm not sure how this is?

[Faylaa]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 8t6Y4qB2RQ

is this fair? im not quiet sure

[DuckGoesRawr]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=37530279&userid=409019&signature=v8WK9Bgj3iNp8t6Y4qB2RQ

is this fair? im not quiet sure

Unfair to them, their very rare dog alone would be slight overpay ^^