The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread -READ 2ND POST-

[Chaosin]

just got this bid

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 7Xz8OHWvfg - fair?

Pretty sure it's about worth that many assorted '09 rares, so unfair to you due to the years on some of their pets.
Might want a second opinion though.

I actually think it's far. The dog with purple sparkles is an '09 dog. If you factor in the spot on the list, and the fact it's a rat, that should be fair.

[Endoo]

Is this fair? Thanks in advance!

I believe it's unfair to them. ^^;
I'd get another opinion just to be safe!

More opinions?

[1120]

Is this worth a Shima Longtail? If not, what do I add to make it worth a Shima Longtail?

Ok. c: So it's worth about an early 2010 rare, so no. You could add another 2010 to make it rarity-wise, but they'd probably want overpay for the demand. Depends on how they value their shima longtail.

Late 2009 rare
Late 2012 rare
late 2009 uncommon
Does this seem a little more fair (not including kitsune mask), along with a few Easter pets?
Guys, I really want advice on this.

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

just got this bid

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 7Xz8OHWvfg - fair?

Pretty sure it's about worth that many assorted '09 rares, so unfair to you due to the years on some of their pets.
Might want a second opinion though.

I actually think it's far. The dog with purple sparkles is an '09 dog. If you factor in the spot on the list, and the fact it's a rat, that should be fair.

its unfair to the rat
That tier is worth five mixed 09 rares. Meaning they'd need to add a late 09 rare or early 2010 rare to be fair

[Thymermaid]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... t5zegmHMgg

fair or who should add?

[KathrynKat]

Bids made so far:

Bid 1

Bid 2

(took 3 off since it's very bad...)

Bid 4

Bid 5

Bid 6

Alright I just need to know with only SO FAR, which might be the best 2, I'm auctioning off my Sun Jewel

[1120]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=36135363&userid=608064&signature=74QADCWcYTaQt5zegmHMgg

fair or who should add?

Unfair to them.

[Phione Mango]

hia, I have tried to trade twice, but they have both rejected, I thought they were fair trades, were they? this is the first one, and the very rare pet was on their wishlist. This was the second one, and at the time both pets I offered them were wishlist pets. They both said nothing that they would 'overpay' for wishlist pets, or anything like that.

[Yuuya Kizami]

Hey, Is this fair?
I'm unsure because the UR aussie is pretty close to the Zebra?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... UGQj-O_a_A

[username loading]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... jQ55vr8eJQ
was this fair?