The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Wingless Angel.]

Is this fair?? Thank you so much

[Topiratti]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=35653028&userid=378498&signature=kUDJXu9N5ELS0suzW4Yddg

Is this a fair trade? c: Or near fair? c: -wants the ghostie-

That is unfair to you. Quite unfair in fact.
The dog is from 2008, keeping in mind c;
Get a second opinion in case I am wrong.

is this fair? if not which side is it unfair too? im the one with the 4 pets (09/10)

Unfair to you.

That dog has been a priority for me for quite a while now. I really hope I'm offering a fair trade to them...

That was quite unfair to them.
But, they were happy, accepted it, so I suppose you're all good ^^

what do i need to remove to make it fair?

[nattlikeschips]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=35657421&userid=5911&signature=gRbB0uk74nuWXVdILiSquQ

i'm sorry for spamming this trade, but i know jack about demand and rarity

Looks like it would be unfair to you, I'd get a second opinion thouugh

[LaceWhiskey]

Is this fair? I not, what could be added?
Thanks.
Trade Link

[HeartBeat]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... iaNnH2duHg

Is this fair? Thanks!

[ahirked]

I'm just curious but is this fair?

It happened a long time ago, and I am quite bad with demand-wise pets, so I would like some opinions ^^
And tell me what I should have added/taken away.

Is this fair?? Thank you so much

Well your side has store items, so I suppose that is unfair to you.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=35657421&userid=5911&signature=gRbB0uk74nuWXVdILiSquQ

i'm sorry for spamming this trade, but i know jack about demand and rarity

Looks like it would be unfair to you, I'd get a second opinion thouugh

Your opinion is the second ^^

@Topiratti: I think you should remove the '09's and one '10, but please get a second opinion.
Either way, remove at least 3 of the dogs on your side.

Is this fair? I not, what could be added?
Thanks.
Trade Link

Top is overpaying.
Store pets are worth roughly an '09 rare.
Sorry I keep confusing myself that Store pets are worth an '09 rare.

[Chipchap]

Is this fair? ;o; If not, what shall be added on which side?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ylrwgOvz2Q
Thanks!

Thanks! What can be added on her side?

Not completely sure but I would say around a mid-early '10 rare but please get a second opinion

Can I have an second opinion??

[DerbyGirl]

Is this fair? I not, what could be added?
Thanks.
Trade Link

@Polo-tay please don't give out false information. The corgi is only worth a mid '10 rare, not an '09 rare.

I'd go fair or slightly unfair to you on this one.

[Rbpuppy]

Is this fair? I not, what could be added?
Thanks.
Trade Link

Top is overpaying.
Store pets are worth roughly an '09 rare.

Please don't give false advice. It's unfair to Lace.

[Sonmi-451]

Is this fair? I not, what could be added?
Thanks.
Trade Link

Top is overpaying.
Store pets are worth roughly an '09 rare.

Please don't give false advice. It's unfair to Lace.

I agree with Polo-Tay, actually, considering that there is a May '10 rare as well as the store corgi on the top.