The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[TrulyBrilliant]

So I was originally sent this, which I know is unfair to me, but they said I could edit as I please.

I'm wondering if any one of these rares/mix of these rares would make it a fairer trade? Thank you!

If you added all of those, it would still be unfair to you.

I thought that may be the case. About how many 2012 rares would I have to add to make it fair? They have a few others I could add.

[Applenz]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=35075005&userid=98981&signature=DnYNqb7nxDPOPfA_Q7lv8Q
Is this fair?

quite unfair to you.

Thank you
Could I get a second opinion
Also how can I make it fair to both of us.
Any good help much appreciated

[resque]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=35075005&userid=98981&signature=DnYNqb7nxDPOPfA_Q7lv8Q
Is this fair? :)

quite unfair to you.

Thank you :)
Could I get a second opinion
Also how can I make it fair to both of us.
Any good help much appreciated :)

a light leopard is worth roughly two mid advents and an early 09' rare, according to the gap break down list;
viewtopic.php?p=56479868#p56479868

Your desert swirl PPS and Santa cat, along with one-two mid 09' rares should be about fair. remove everything else, otherwise.

[julia49781]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=34651091&userid=339345&signature=hw5yPra23n9YvkclAMYiiQ
Fair? Thanks in advance! c: If not what should be added/removed?

[littlesnow30805]

I Would Say Fair To You

[starshooter102]

is this trade fair? I'm not really sure on the rarity of the PPS owl
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=35052622&userid=4017&signature=WWCbUEdO1kjjKriIV_RMSw

Unfair to you

What should be removed?

[Inska]

So I was originally sent this, which I know is unfair to me, but they said I could edit as I please.

I'm wondering if any one of these rares/mix of these rares would make it a fairer trade? Thank you!

If you added all of those, it would still be unfair to you.

I thought that may be the case. About how many 2012 rares would I have to add to make it fair? They have a few others I could add.

I'd say about 4 others, but you might want another opinion, I'm not the best with non-list quantity ^^;

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... vkclAMYiiQ
Fair? Thanks in advance! c: If not what should be added/removed?

Seems roughly fair, but it would help if you could add how many horses they're asking for.

is this trade fair? I'm not really sure on the rarity of the PPS owl
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=35052622&userid=4017&signature=WWCbUEdO1kjjKriIV_RMSw

Unfair to you

What should be removed?

I'd say keep the rare, the 2 '09 UCs and 4-6 early '10 UCs.

[CelestialEclipse]

Is this fair?http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=35076001&userid=520948&signature=Na9Yng38WXbtNiT4zgXswQ

Originally they asked for the Spotted Light Blue Leopard Dog(I don't know it's official name) in return for the two Zodiac Dogs, but they wanted me to add more. I offered them my Orange Retro or my 'Paris' horse. So is it fair with the Orange Retro? If not, who is it unfair to?

[lesbian]

Hey.

I'm curious if this is fair to either of us.

Haha, I'm pretty clueless at trading. c:

[MalkbieTradeLeaves]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... m4q1xKc0nA
Is this fair?
(Note: I'm giving away MOST of my pets here...)