The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[dori.]

Is this fair?

[only]

Another Unknown Rarity vs. Rare query for you.
Okay, so, here's what they sent.
I'm at loss as to what to do, since jester pets seem to turn out to be pretty popular. I mean, take the jester dogs, the pair is quite popular nowadays. And I have this feeling that that lion will be quite rare. I know you shouldn't listen to rumours like this, but... It seems likely looking at his patterns and things. I don't have many rares, so this could be a problem for me. Any help would be appreciated c:

[WinterWildfire]

Thank you, Inska. Do you know about unfair it is, what I could add?

You would need to add between a '09 UR dog and a red tox or so.

Thanks!

[Yoyce]

Another Unknown Rarity vs. Rare query for you.
Okay, so, here's what they sent.
I'm at loss as to what to do, since jester pets seem to turn out to be pretty popular. I mean, take the jester dogs, the pair is quite popular nowadays. And I have this feeling that that lion will be quite rare. I know you shouldn't listen to rumours like this, but... It seems likely looking at his patterns and things. I don't have many rares, so this could be a problem for me. Any help would be appreciated c:

Even if it will be rare (I don't really think so), it's unfair to them, their pet is almost 4 years older.

[Inska]

Is this fair?

Unfair to them, the Scarf Dog + the rares would be enough.

Another Unknown Rarity vs. Rare query for you.
Okay, so, here's what they sent.
I'm at loss as to what to do, since jester pets seem to turn out to be pretty popular. I mean, take the jester dogs, the pair is quite popular nowadays. And I have this feeling that that lion will be quite rare. I know you shouldn't listen to rumours like this, but... It seems likely looking at his patterns and things. I don't have many rares, so this could be a problem for me. Any help would be appreciated c:

Might be worth taking. There are too many of the lion for it to be very rare, and even if it turns out to be rare, the pony is worth 10 of them. The demand will fade eventually (Lynx PPS, SoulWings PPS) and the lion will go for a '12 rare at most in a few weeks/months. Probably.

[only]

Is this fair?

Unfair to them, the Scarf Dog + the rares would be enough.

Another Unknown Rarity vs. Rare query for you.
Okay, so, here's what they sent.
I'm at loss as to what to do, since jester pets seem to turn out to be pretty popular. I mean, take the jester dogs, the pair is quite popular nowadays. And I have this feeling that that lion will be quite rare. I know you shouldn't listen to rumours like this, but... It seems likely looking at his patterns and things. I don't have many rares, so this could be a problem for me. Any help would be appreciated c:

Might be worth taking. There are too many of the lion for it to be very rare, and even if it turns out to be rare, the pony is worth 10 of them. The demand will fade eventually (Lynx PPS, SoulWings PPS) and the lion will go for a '12 rare at most in a few weeks/months. Probably.

Another Unknown Rarity vs. Rare query for you.
Okay, so, here's what they sent.
I'm at loss as to what to do, since jester pets seem to turn out to be pretty popular. I mean, take the jester dogs, the pair is quite popular nowadays. And I have this feeling that that lion will be quite rare. I know you shouldn't listen to rumours like this, but... It seems likely looking at his patterns and things. I don't have many rares, so this could be a problem for me. Any help would be appreciated c:

Even if it will be rare (I don't really think so), it's unfair to them, their pet is almost 4 years older.

Thanks Inska and Yoyce, you were of great help to me c: I might just decline the trade. I will feel bad because it's such overpay. I want to earn rares by myself really, not by taking advantage of other people who desperately want pets.

[Purplegirlknits]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Ydzx21cfWQ

is this fair? I dont think so but what could be added

[luca.]

Is this a fair trade :')?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 7zPiX3Orlw

[DerbyGirl]

Is this a fair trade :')?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 7zPiX3Orlw

Until rarities are known it is hard to say, but will most likely be unfair to top.

[Apate]

Fair