The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Foxen]

Is this a fair trade?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Y32tm94Xdw
Thanks please pm me

Quit unfair to you (:

[LLHBBB]

I have been told before since the 2nd generation pets and the warrior pets were both released for several months back in '08-'09 that you can't go but just the dates. Is that correct and would that make this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ExqZwy0odg

Unfair to them, you should add a late 2012 rare to stitch up the large month gap. (:

Is there anyone on who is familiar with 2nd generation older pets? Because I know for a fact both the 2nd generation dogs and the warrior cats have multiply release dates so you can't just look at the dates at face value. The warrior cat here is showing in the archives from Jan '09 but as you can clearly see they were still being release in '10.

[DerbyGirl]

I have been told before since the 2nd generation pets and the warrior pets were both released for several months back in '08-'09 that you can't go but just the dates. Is that correct and would that make this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ExqZwy0odg

Unfair to them, you should add a late 2012 rare to stitch up the large month gap. (:

Is there anyone on who is familiar with 2nd generation older pets? Because I know for a fact both the 2nd generation dogs and the warrior cats have multiply release dates so you can't just look at the dates at face value. The warrior cat here is showing in the archives from Jan '09 but as you can clearly see they were still being release in '10.

The dog is worth about a mid '09 rare due to long availability.

The cat is worth a late '09 to early '10 rare due to long availability. Personally, I would add at least another early '10 rare.

[Butt3rflyJB]

Is this fair for a NonCoon? I've been getting mixed replies, so I would like just one or two more opinions please.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 5QLgMWGS3Q

Thanks

[trashcan't]

Is this fair for a NonCoon? I've been getting mixed replies, so I would like just one or two more opinions please.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 5QLgMWGS3Q

Thanks

Its unfair? Non-coon is main list ( i think, cant remember X3 ) and there is none list pet maybe one on the other side

[Lady Sif]

I have been told before since the 2nd generation pets and the warrior pets were both released for several months back in '08-'09 that you can't go but just the dates. Is that correct and would that make this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ExqZwy0odg

Unfair to them, you should add a late 2012 rare to stitch up the large month gap. (:

Is there anyone on who is familiar with 2nd generation older pets? Because I know for a fact both the 2nd generation dogs and the warrior cats have multiply release dates so you can't just look at the dates at face value. The warrior cat here is showing in the archives from Jan '09 but as you can clearly see they were still being release in '10.

viewtopic.php?f=20&t=1812615

There's a whole guide on the matter. The 2nd gen was adoptable through august of 2009. Warriors don't have pictures on the guide because of how many of them there are. Just ctrl-f warriors.

[DerbyGirl]

s this fair for a NonCoon? I've been getting mixed replies, so I would like just one or two more opinions please.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 5QLgMWGS3Q

Thanks

Its unfair? Non-coon is main list ( i think, cant remember X3 ) and there is none list pet maybe one on the other side

There is, the GWJ. Please only give educated answers.

I would still have to go unfair to Noncoon, the gap between the GWJ and Noncoon is much larger than some recent random rares and store pets.

[Gurl]

which one of these trades is would you accept for the orange warrior cat?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... RFUwFy4Yxg

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... vjCX2Fq2aw

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... QmnqdZ-Htw


I think 3rd one would be b est because warrior for warrior would be good (: P.S i didnt quots x3

[Lady Sif]

Is this fair for a NonCoon? I've been getting mixed replies, so I would like just one or two more opinions please.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 5QLgMWGS3Q

Thanks

[/quote]

Its unfair? Non-coon is main list ( i think, cant remember X3 ) and there is none list pet maybe one on the other side[/quote]
Unfair to you. About a red toxic or 09 UR dog needs to be added on their side.

A GWJ is worth 2 sorbets and a UR apple verses a non-coon which is worth 3 sorbets.

[LLHBBB]

There's a whole guide on the matter. The 2nd gen was adoptable through august of 2009. Warriors don't have pictures on the guide because of how many of them there are. Just ctrl-f warriors.[/quote]

Thank you this is what I was looking for!