The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[CelestialEclipse]

((The orange one is '09 Orange Retro, even though it says '13, that's because it was a December 18th pet)) http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=34211754&userid=520948&signature=qqxfXZrzsT_iUFDpfErq5w

I'm not sure if a '09 rare is the same value as a '12 very rare or if it's an up or downgrade. Is this better for me, them, or is it fair?

Unfair to you.

So what would make it fair? I'm assuming another '09 rare, but I'm not sure about demand.

[Selenea]

I could use some help please
Those are bids for my store pet auction:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=33989105&userid=477930&signature=fH4BXRp4FmvH-gENH9_ipg
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=33766556&userid=477930&signature=5SDNq0Kmb-bpZGw_WN66yQ
For my C$ auction:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=34156470&userid=477930&signature=5uiETMGUue7I85tFs2VGkw
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=34157982&userid=477930&signature=6LdOX-V1DBzPxtrUYGi-aw

Also what would be fair for an Eat Me?
B&W Point-eared Border Collie + ??? = Eat Me

Thanks a lot!

Please don't give out false information.

Store pet = '10 rare NOT '09

Thanks a lot and what about the other auction?

[ahirked]

Which bid is better?

1
Or...
2

[Yoyce]

Is this a fair trade please?
I'm not sure how much whole set is worth. Please answer only if You're sure, don't guess. ^^

[snowdrake]

Is this a fair trade please?
I'm not sure how much whole set is worth. Please answer only if You're sure, don't guess. ^^

I would say its a little bit unfair to you...I think 5 C$ more an it would be fair c:
But I think you should wait for more opinions c:

[ahirked]

Which bid is better?

1
Or...
2

[A Random Moustache]

What is better:

This or this?

[CelestialEclipse]

((The orange one is '09 Orange Retro, even though it says '13, that's because it was a December 18th pet)) http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=34211754&userid=520948&signature=qqxfXZrzsT_iUFDpfErq5w

I'm not sure if a '09 rare is the same value as a '12 very rare or if it's an up or downgrade. Is this better for me, them, or is it fair?

Unfair to you.

Oh! Thank you so much ^^
Also,
What would make it fair? I'm assuming another '09 rare, but I'm not sure about demand.

[ahirked]

What is better:

This or this?

Any rare = around 20 uncommons from the same year
My bad >.<

So I'd say the first one, however the Scourge cat has a higher demand.

I would enquire in the "How Much Is This Pet Worth?" Thread, found here

[DerbyGirl]

((The orange one is '09 Orange Retro, even though it says '13, that's because it was a December 18th pet)) http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=34211754&userid=520948&signature=qqxfXZrzsT_iUFDpfErq5w

I'm not sure if a '09 rare is the same value as a '12 very rare or if it's an up or downgrade. Is this better for me, them, or is it fair?

Unfair to you.

Oh! Thank you so much ^^
Also,
What would make it fair? I'm assuming another '09 rare, but I'm not sure about demand.

An early '10 rare or an 09 uncommon or two should be fine. Their dog is just about worth an late 09 rare.

Which bid is better?

1
Or...
2

The second one.

What is better:

This or this?

Any rare = around 20 uncommons from the same year

So I'd say the first one, however the Scourge cat has a higher demand.

I would enquire in the "How Much Is This Pet Worth?" Thread, found here

Do not give out false information. A rare is generally worth 4-6 uncommons of the same year, depending on the pets involved.

The first one is the better offer. The Scourge is only worth a early '10 uncommon due to being available until early 2010.