The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[ClockworkCoyote]

PM me with a reply for a gift<3
send me wrong advice and i will foe you i need help to make this fair.

Don't threaten to foe people, it's rude

It looks about fair if slightly unfair to you

people send me advice so wrong that when i cancel saying "this is really unfair, sorry" they foe ME and send rude messages. i'm so sick of it, and it happens alot... :\

[Airris]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... XlmOdSN7Qg
I was wondering if I could get another opinion? I have two people saying it is unfair to the top, and one saying it is slight overpay for the bottom...? Thank you for all who help me!

[Takk]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... XlmOdSN7Qg
I was wondering if I could get another opinion? I have two people saying it is unfair to the top, and one saying it is slight overpay for the bottom...? Thank you for all who help me!

It's unfair to the top because the rare is WORTH a mid '11 uncommon if it helps

[Darkky]

Uhhh. I really like my dog, but the horse is pretty cool too. If you can tell how fair this is in both rarity AND demand that would be great! {Unless you don't know one, but you know the other I would still accept your opinion. But I still need both of those -rarity and demand-}
{x}
Thanks in advance!

Nobody?

[Petterz]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... AUroJ-O8sw can someone please help me? I am really not great with items

[Ironic Equation]

Uhhh. I really like my dog, but the horse is pretty cool too. If you can tell how fair this is in both rarity AND demand that would be great! {Unless you don't know one, but you know the other I would still accept your opinion. But I still need both of those -rarity and demand-}
{x}
Thanks in advance!

Nobody?

I would say unfair to you

[amethyst,]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=33861294&userid=142660&signature=Vrx_lxIEAHf0AUroJ-O8sw can someone please help me? I am really not great with items

I believe that this is unfair to the person that has all of the pets on their side (like the lion). But you may want a second opinion. c:

[MotleyPlaysArk]

1. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 9XhBHFv0uA

Fair? Valuing the UR Holly at a UR Lion.

2. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... YOtHmdGXfA
This one is for the U-Nick-Corn

7th time... please anyone?

[katespets]

Any ideas?

[MotleyPlaysArk]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=33861294&userid=142660&signature=Vrx_lxIEAHf0AUroJ-O8sw can someone please help me? I am really not great with items

I believe that this is unfair to the person that has all of the pets on their side (like the lion). But you may want a second opinion. c:

I second that.