The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Olivesaurus]

kk, ima accept then!

im stumped.. is this fair? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... JQpX1fWh8Q

Edit: Could i have a second opionion? thank you all!

Unfair to them c:

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

Is my bid fair? Just wanted to double check~

Thanks in advance c:

-Estella

Totally fair. :3

Don't give false advice please
Unfair to the bottom by a lot.

[Tayrisha]

Hello ^^

I just make auction for my growing Sun-jewel and I want ask, what do you think about these bids, please?

Are they fair, unfair or what do you think?

bid 1

bid 2

bid 3

bid 4

Thanks for your time and any answer. ^^

I would say
2
1
3
4 I don't believe four is fair unless I'm missing something

Oh wait missed the line tribal for four. Umm not sure if it's unfair now. It is probably fair to be honest

Oh, ok. ^^ Thanks for information.

[lrjj]

Is my bid fair? Just wanted to double check~

Thanks in advance c:

-Estella

I would say unfair to you. The horse is quite low on the list so isn't worth much more than 4-6 '09 rares (someone correct me if I'm wrong) there are quite a few pets in there on your side making it unfair to you

[The Last Raven]

Is this fair? I'm not sure about the C$

Well on the worth in C$ thread it says early '09 rares/very rares are worth C$35-40 each. These are late '08 and are probably worth a little but more but it is quite fair maybe between 5-20 C$ between them
Edits* sorry I keep forgetting things

Ok thanks! Second opinion possibly?

[Tea.Time]

is this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... UiXdSE4D9w

thanks!

Quoting for the [sense i want the trade as much as they do?]

I price around...65c$ for advent bw, 30c$ each for others , 35c$ for the Black Rainbow-Striped Dog- comes to about 220c$ so you are overpaying in my point of view.

i priced them using the what is it worth thread though, which from my understanding is accurate?

[qraphic]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... gYqbU3yv0g

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... skY0_ybSQA

do either one? If so, which one and if not, what would make make it fair?

[Smamm]

Is this trade fair?

[Mirah_]

Hi! Do you know if this trade is fair?
If not, what can be changed? Thank you C:

Not good with "common" pets at all, the reason why I skipped ya (and items) but if I were to make a decision, slightly unfair to you?? All of your pets are dogs, which in general are higher than rats and bunnies.

Thank you very much C: Could I have a second opinion please?

[crucifying.]

Hello ^^

I just make auction for my growing Sun-jewel and I want ask, what do you think about these bids, please?

Are they fair, unfair or what do you think?

bid 1

bid 2

bid 3

bid 4

Number one is the best. Number 2 doesn't even compare to 1.