The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Kornelia]

--snip--

Or this?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... p--KfHxY9g

I think it's a little unfair for the Grinner.

So what can be added?

[Gwenfoxe]

is this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... wKvz-io9VA

Unfair to them.

[frozenintheflames]

Thanks for the help on the last trade, everyone! c:
Can someone tell me how I can make this trade fairer to them? According to the $C - Pet thread, their pet is worth about 15+ C$. I added in the pets too, which are all on their wishlist, because their pet has such high demand, even though it's in a trade group.
But. I still don't think it's fair What else should I add? I have rares, but none were on their wishlist. What else would be suitable, rarity, demand, and date-wise?
Thanks!

[pew]

Is this trade fair? If not, how can I make it fair?

Thank you

Thanks for the help on the last trade, everyone! c:
Can someone tell me how I can make this trade fairer to them? According to the $C - Pet thread, their pet is worth about 15+ C$. I added in the pets too, which are all on their wishlist, because their pet has such high demand, even though it's in a trade group.
But. I still don't think it's fair What else should I add? I have rares, but none were on their wishlist. What else would be suitable, rarity, demand, and date-wise?
Thanks!

The raven dog is worth way more C$ than that,
I think it's about 50-60 C$

The dog is on the advent list, which makes this trade extremely unfair to them.

['Possum]

is this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... wKvz-io9VA

Unfair to them.

How so? The Store cat was only available if you bought the whole set for 60CS$.
There are a lot of people who consider it worth that much because you had to pay that in order to get it. Sort of a special release store pet.
Even if you don't consider that, a current store pet costs 20CS$ to purchase. Once they're retired their value in CS$ goes up over time.
For these reasons that cat alone is definitely worth at least 20CS$ The other pets on top of that are just extra and make it even more unfair for the store cat side.

[Kornelia]

--snip--

Or this?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... p--KfHxY9g

I think it's a little unfair for the Grinner.

So what can be added?

[Yoyce]

is this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... wKvz-io9VA

Unfair to them.

How so? The Store cat was only available if you bought the whole set for 60CS$.
There are a lot of people who consider it worth that much because you had to pay that in order to get it. Sort of a special release store pet.
Even if you don't consider that, a current store pet costs 20CS$ to purchase. Once they're retired their value in CS$ goes up over time.
For these reasons that cat alone is definitely worth at least 20CS$ The other pets on top of that are just extra and make it even more unfair for the store cat side.

That's exactly what Gwenfoxe wrote, unfair to them -> unfair to the Cat side, right?

['Possum]

is this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... wKvz-io9VA

Unfair to them.

How so? The Store cat was only available if you bought the whole set for 60CS$.
There are a lot of people who consider it worth that much because you had to pay that in order to get it. Sort of a special release store pet.
Even if you don't consider that, a current store pet costs 20CS$ to purchase. Once they're retired their value in CS$ goes up over time.
For these reasons that cat alone is definitely worth at least 20CS$ The other pets on top of that are just extra and make it even more unfair for the store cat side.

That's exactly what Gwenfoxe wrote, unfair to them -> unfair to the Cat side, right?

Gah! XD My bad! I read it wrong. Yes, unfair to the store cat side any way you look at it. Sorry! I'm a ditz this morning. Should know better than to be on here before my 2nd cup of coffee.

[XXAspenXX]

How so? The Store cat was only available if you bought the whole set for 60CS$.
There are a lot of people who consider it worth that much because you had to pay that in order to get it. Sort of a special release store pet.
Even if you don't consider that, a current store pet costs 20CS$ to purchase. Once they're retired their value in CS$ goes up over time.
For these reasons that cat alone is definitely worth at least 20CS$ The other pets on top of that are just extra and make it even more unfair for the store cat side.[/quote]

That's exactly what Gwenfoxe wrote, unfair to them -> unfair to the Cat side, right?

Gah! XD My bad! I read it wrong. Yes, unfair to the store cat side any way you look at it. Sorry! I'm a ditz this morning. Should know better than to be on here before my 2nd cup of coffee. [/quote]

Ok thank you all so much for helping me!

[radiantly]

Thanks for all the help. Could you please help make this fair?

Any suggestions ?