The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Estella Noire]

I am holding an auction and I have some big numbers. I'm bad enough at rarities as it is, never mind in these huge quantities! I wondered if someone could give me a hand at judging which is most valuable? The bids are as follows:

bid 1
this & this & this
2087 pets -- 1 advent list, 26 on my wishlist
41 items

bid 2
this
188 pets -- 111 wishlist, 1 main list, 1 advent list

bid 3
everything on this account
3350 pets -- 2 advent list, ~60 wishlist
some items

---

All help greatly appreciated! Thank you :3

-Estella

I believe the first bid is the best( is it all of them?)
But it depends on whether you like quantity or quality. If quantity is what you like, the last one. You might want a second opinion since my computer couldn't load the pictures for most of them.

{third looks to be the best.
it holds the same pets as the first from what I saw. and there are two advent list and more wishlist.
thats my professional opinion.

The first was the one I rated the lowest. When you prefere quantity take 3. Case you like Main list and wishlist take two. The first I saw were many store pets and many doubles, but I don't know eyactly the worth of the items
But all trades are not bad(don't know what your offering so that might be a little complicated)
Whatever you take there are some pets in each trade that I personally would like. Try to think about the pets you like most, do you prefere dogs, horses, warriors or other. Than go trough the trades and count the pets you really like about it.

Thank you for all your opinions

[unikornie]

]quote="~ t r o u b l e ~"]

I am holding an auction and I have some big numbers. I'm bad enough at rarities as it is, never mind in these huge quantities! I wondered if someone could give me a hand at judging which is most valuable? The bids are as follows:

bid 1
this & this & this
2087 pets -- 1 advent list, 26 on my wishlist
41 items

bid 2
this
188 pets -- 111 wishlist, 1 main list, 1 advent list

bid 3
everything on this account
3350 pets -- 2 advent list, ~60 wishlist
some items

---

All help greatly appreciated! Thank you :3

-Estella

I believe the first bid is the best( is it all of them?)
But it depends on whether you like quantity or quality. If quantity is what you like, the last one. You might want a second opinion since my computer couldn't load the pictures for most of them.

{third looks to be the best.
it holds the same pets as the first from what I saw. and there are two advent list and more wishlist.
thats my professional opinion.

[/quote]

The first was the one I rated the lowest. When you prefere quantity take 3. Case you like Main list and wishlist take two. The first I saw were many store pets and many doubles, but I don't know eyactly the worth of the items
But all trades are not bad(don't know what your offering so that might be a little complicated)
Whatever you take there are some pets in each trade that I personally would like. Try to think about the pets you like most, do you prefere dogs, horses, warriors or other. Than go trough the trades and count the pets you really like about it.

Thank you for all your opinions

[/quote]

What are you auctioning exactly?

[icerod146]

Hey all. Would you guys mind double checking this one? Thank you. :] -AvelynnRose
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... AUy7amGx9Q

Unfair to you about a late '09 rare or '10 ^-^

{I disagree.
Looks fine to me

[/quote]

I agree if you don't care about dates.

I'm not sure who you're agreeing with icerod146 but dates are quite important so I'm not sure why you'd give advice disregarding them?
Anyway - I agree with Trouble. [/quote]
I donot trade that way, that's just it. We all trade our own way yes?

[Selenea]

Hey guys I need your help
I know this trade is not fair but what should be added to make it fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=31710091&userid=477930&signature=PWTWDiFtxWB4yhhPBLMZvA
Thanks so much for your advice!

[booklover789]

While I'm not a newbie here on CS, I do have quite a bit of difficulty trading, and would appreciate some help with the trades below. I'm not sure if they're fair or not...and if they're not fair, what should I do to make them more fair?

1. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... sQfnzDbBuw

2. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 1L4MwhHhgA

3. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... cRAM_JghNg

[Jaskiest]

While I'm not a newbie here on CS, I do have quite a bit of difficulty trading, and would appreciate some help with the trades below. I'm not sure if they're fair or not...and if they're not fair, what should I do to make them more fair?

1. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... sQfnzDbBuw

2. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 1L4MwhHhgA

3. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... cRAM_JghNg

I believe those are all unfair to the bottom, unsure what should be added though, sorry.

[Mavric]

I am unsure about quantity trades, and would love an educated response for this, and advice for what to add/remove. Thank you so very much for your advice!
~Mavric

[Not me nope]

So the above for an eat me dog? Or am I still over paying?

[Kyar]

I am unsure about quantity trades, and would love an educated response for this, and advice for what to add/remove. Thank you so very much for your advice!
~Mavric

Unfair to you by about a low main list. I'd say something around a skeleton PPS or so. :)

Edit:

So the above for an eat me dog? Or am I still over paying?

Unfair to you. :) If you took off the roadkill pony it would be fair. :) Unless the zebra is VR now which it might be - I can't remember. In that case the eat me would need to add about an 09 rare or so to make up for that. :)

[Estella Noire]

I am holding an auction and I have some big numbers. I'm bad enough at rarities as it is, never mind in these huge quantities! I wondered if someone could give me a hand at judging which is most valuable? The bids are as follows:

bid 1
this & this & this
2087 pets -- 1 advent list, 26 on my wishlist
41 items

bid 2
this
188 pets -- 111 wishlist, 1 main list, 1 advent list

bid 3
everything on this account
3350 pets -- 2 advent list, ~60 wishlist
some items

---

All help greatly appreciated! Thank you :3

-Estella

The first was the one I rated the lowest. When you prefere quantity take 3. Case you like Main list and wishlist take two. The first I saw were many store pets and many doubles, but I don't know eyactly the worth of the items
But all trades are not bad(don't know what your offering so that might be a little complicated)
Whatever you take there are some pets in each trade that I personally would like. Try to think about the pets you like most, do you prefere dogs, horses, warriors or other. Than go trough the trades and count the pets you really like about it.

What are you auctioning exactly?

An infinitely upgraded Eqcetera game account.