The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Simon]

Is this a fair trade?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=31716034&userid=368658&signature=FA5T67JSPUbmb_1sZP0eeg

unfair to you

[Takk]

I feel like this was really unfair, am I wrong?

Yes, it was unfair to you even adding up item rarities

[FluffySoul]

Is this fair?
Not sure if I need to add more.
Thanks!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... LhpT7-cyIg

[EmilineRose]

would a 2009 rare be worth this guy

or what should be added?

Depends on the Rare and how early/late it was released. If their offering something of early '09 it's unfair to them. It also depends on the person
But I'm also not great with gaps, so I could be wrong

{no matter what rare from 09 is offered, it'd unfair to the 09. the dog is worth an early 2010 rare at most.

would a 2009 rare be worth this guy

or what should be added?

Depends on the Rare and how early/late it was released. If their offering something of early '09 it's unfair to them. It also depends on the person

I would say that an 09 rare would be overpay for the dog. An early 10 rare would be plenty.

Okay Thank you guys!! <3 ^_^

[Kyar]

Is this fair?
Not sure if I need to add more.
Thanks!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... LhpT7-cyIg

It's a bit unfair to them. I think you need to add roughly a grinner or so. :)

[Violet2sweet]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... b_2wst5lwg

What should be taken away or added if needed?

[Spearow]

This is massive overpay on their part, is it not?
X

[qittenpie]

Hey, would anyone mind checking this trade for me? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... QARYDXWWCA

I know my side is lacking, but would a Grinner make it fair or would it still be unbalanced for someone? (Alternately, if I could pull a Grinner out for it, what could be taken out on my side?)

Thanks!

[Spearow]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=31706822&userid=538664&signature=uxQoNw4zLgJC4V5vQ_aDQA

Is this fair?

second opinion?

Unfair to them.

Agreed. ^^ And the Zodiac dogs are pretty popular.

[catsmeow]

Is this fair? I really love these horses a lot but the pup is cute too. Thanks!