The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread - Please use this one!

[Raloi]

Guys, I'm seriously freaking out. Someone sent me this trade and I have no idea what to do... Should I decline? Should I edit and if so, how? Is it worth trading away all of my scythes(I mean, obviously it is, I'm talking about if they will be obtainable seeing the demand for them?(Not to mention that I may accept another trade that includes one of my scythes) asdfghjkl

[e-sheep]

I think this is unfair to them. If I remove all pets on both sides, would it be fair then?

[Kyar]

Guys, I'm seriously freaking out. Someone sent me this trade and I have no idea what to do... Should I decline? Should I edit and if so, how? Is it worth trading away all of my scythes?(Not to mention that I may accept another trade that includes one of my scythes) asdfghjkl

Well their offer is extreme overpay in all senses - really just a few pets or newer items on their side should be more than enough.
I couldn't possibly imagine valuing each scythe as more than a late 2013 uncommon.

[Lynx23]

Is this a fair trade? I honestly don't know >.<

Edit: If you can, a speedy reply would be nice ^^; I don't want them to have to wait to long. Sorry!

[Kyo]

Hi! Sorry if this is the wrong place for this, but I could really use some advice! I'm hosting an auction for 106 tokens, and have three lovely bids I'm having a very hard time choosing over at the moment. Could anyone offer me a little advice on which would be the better offer? Thanks for your time!

Bid 1
Bid 2
Bid 3

I love all the 08's in bid 1, bid 2 has a very nice mixture, and bid three is a hight advent dog! Which would you pick if you were me?

[OKaP]

I haven't really traded items for pets before.
Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... d=31155801

[TheUmbraSide]

Is this a fair trade? I honestly don't know >.<

Edit: If you can, a speedy reply would be nice ^^; I don't want them to have to wait to long. Sorry!

I think it's fair-maybe tiny bit unfair to you.

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

Is this a fair trade? I honestly don't know >.<

Edit: If you can, a speedy reply would be nice ^^; I don't want them to have to wait to long. Sorry!

I think it's fair-maybe tiny bit unfair to you.

➴------------------------------------------------------------
{looks unfair to them honestly.
the gap isn't a 2010 rare ^^
----------------------------------------------------------------➶

[_Leopard_]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... lM4LPPAz8A Is this fair? If not what needs to be added? Thanks for your help!

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=31191926&userid=560530&signature=97Dq8MmJRz43lM4LPPAz8A Is this fair? If not what needs to be added? Thanks for your help!

➴------------------------------------------------------------
{unfair to the holly fox by about a first tier advent or 3 09 rares ^^
----------------------------------------------------------------➶