The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread - Please use this one!

[Miikkuli90]

Hi! I have an offer with a 2008 very rare that isn't on the lists, but since I've no idea what this is worth, I wanted to ask for someone's opinion: Is this a fair trade?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... kgQDH37BCw

Unfair to you
Your side is worth a second tier advent or so.

Oh, dear! Thank you for answering as I was close to accepting this! ^^ Would the trade be fair if the dragon or the Malk wolf was removed?

[sad dragon]

Is this fair ? >.<

[Dragonborn Comes]

Hi! I have an offer with a 2008 very rare that isn't on the lists, but since I've no idea what this is worth, I wanted to ask for someone's opinion: Is this a fair trade?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... kgQDH37BCw

Unfair to you
Your side is worth a second tier advent or so.

Oh, dear! Thank you for answering as I was close to accepting this! ^^ Would the trade be fair if the dragon or the Malk wolf was removed?

it would then become unfair to them

[Dragonborn Comes]

Is this fair ? >.<

unfair even to rats demand

[sad dragon]

Is this fair ? >.<

unfair even to rats demand

So unfair to the C$ ?

[sanctuary;]

Is this fair?

It may have been answered before but I can't find anything. Thanks c:

Not fair to the bottom, but you should get second opinion

Thanks, what can be done to make it fair? c:

[Miikkuli90]

Hi! I have an offer with a 2008 very rare that isn't on the lists, but since I've no idea what this is worth, I wanted to ask for someone's opinion: Is this a fair trade?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... kgQDH37BCw

Unfair to you
Your side is worth a second tier advent or so.

Thank you for answering as I was close to accepting this! And thank you Moonlight Wolf! ^^ Would the trade be fair if one or two of the music note rares were removed?

[χaphan]

Hi :3
I need some help with this

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... E2eEufkRZA

Thank you :3

[Dragonborn Comes]

@ chasemonster
it is unfair to you

[Dragonborn Comes]

Hi :3
I need some help with this

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... E2eEufkRZA

Thank you :3

unfair to you, the pink dog is on september list and the dog on their side is on the advent list