The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Estella Noire]

Is this a fair trade?
thank you~

[Tikia Thundaren]

Hello again,

Sorry for posting more than one trade in a day, but I have a curiosity question. Was this a fair offer, or at least close to fair? I understand that the Tess dragon has good demand and that there is only a five month difference between them (which is still greater than three months, although granted not by much), but lions generally have excellent demand, so it didn't seem unreasonable for a first offer.

As always, thank you very much for your advice, it is greatly appreciated!

TT

[Estella Noire]

Hello again,

Sorry for posting more than one trade in a day, but I have a curiosity question. Was this a fair offer, or at least close to fair? I understand that the Tess dragon has good demand and that there is only a five month difference between them (which is still greater than three months, although granted not by much), but lions generally have excellent demand, so it didn't seem unreasonable for a first offer.

As always, thank you very much for your advice, it is greatly appreciated!

TT

unfair to them.

[Tikia Thundaren]

Hello again,

Sorry for posting more than one trade in a day, but I have a curiosity question. Was this a fair offer, or at least close to fair? I understand that the Tess dragon has good demand and that there is only a five month difference between them (which is still greater than three months, although granted not by much), but lions generally have excellent demand, so it didn't seem unreasonable for a first offer.

As always, thank you very much for your advice, it is greatly appreciated!

TT

unfair to them.

Thank you for the response! Could I just get some clarification on why? Not old enough, wrong species, etc.?

Are we talking grossly unfair, or just a little bit, which could be fixed easily with an additional pet? I'm sorry, I don't want to be a nuisance, but this seems to be breaking the general guidelines I've been following that a '10 rare is a pretty fair offer for a '11 VR, and I want to make sure I'm offering what the pet is worth.

Thank you to anyone else who responds : )

TT

[melonie]

Palomino tess horse = grinner?

[melonie]

Is this a fair trade?
thank you~

VERY UNFAIR TO THEM

[(DELETE USER)]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... NXbE1t_j2g

Is that worth it? The cat is a re-release...

[Aireiya]

Could I get some help with this trade please? =D
Any help is much appreciated! ^.^

~Jhey

[Yoyce]

Could I get some help with this trade please? =D
Any help is much appreciated! ^.^

~Jhey

The date gap is almost full 3 years and the items aren't worth too much... I wouldn't accept this trade. =)

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=30167313&userid=429810&signature=G8lxAF1aS2uqNXbE1t_j2g

Is that worth it? The cat is a re-release...

The cat is from May 2009 and the dragon from November 2009. The perfect-trade lovers may want You to add a little to cover this little date gap, but I personally [and looks like person who sent the trade too] don't care that much if trading older pets, so yes, trade looks fair.

Palomino tess horse = grinner?

If You look at Septembers List, You'll notice that Palomino Tess Horse is worth more than a Grinner.

[Aireiya]

Could I get some help with this trade please? =D
Any help is much appreciated! ^.^

~Jhey

The date gap is almost full 3 years and the items aren't worth too much... I wouldn't accept this trade. =)

Thanks. =)

~Jhey