The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Nikki Amaranti]

Would this be fair to my Shima? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... c9Hj3N2vRQ Thanks for the help

Unfair to them if we judge by C$ since they offered some.
The Shima is a late 09' Rare, worth 25-30C$.

They offered 20C$.
And the early 2010 rare is worth 25C$.
They're overpaying by C$ standards already.

Rarity-wise, I'm not sure if all the uncommons make up for the gap between 2009 and 2010.
It doesn't seem too unfair or about fair- get more opinions rarity-wise; I'm only sure C$-wise. o u o

_________________________________________________________________

@Tikia Thundaren:

First trade is unfair to you I believe.
I might be wrong, but two rare fishes should be enough for the horse.
They're all from 2009, and the same month.
The fish lineart is a retired lineart as well, so it does have a little more demand as well.

Get more opinions just to be sure. c:
I'm pretty sure 3 fishes would be overpay however.

[undead]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 4J1yA6JExQ

Fair or not? Thanks in advance!

[Sonmi-451]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=29968708&userid=388426&signature=DDee0cuANOpI4J1yA6JExQ

Fair or not? Thanks in advance!

Unfair to you.

[Wookieinmashoo]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=29968714&userid=245926&signature=WSJM-ZvFoeUqyjEdur9hpg

Really looking for some good advice on this trade. I'm trying to figure out just how many 09 rares the patch dog is worth.

EDIT: trade edit.

[Tikia Thundaren]

Hello,

Would this be fair without the guinea pig, the three fish for the horse? Or would it be unfair to the fish?

Also, just got this trade to a tentative conclusion, and neither my partner nor I are entirely sure if it's fair. Are there any item experts lurking out there who could give some good advice? If not I'll comb through the item equivalency guide and see what I can cobble together : )

Thank you so much, as always!

TT

Second and first opinions? : )

TT

[bookworm.]

Hello,

Would this be fair without the guinea pig, the three fish for the horse? Or would it be unfair to the fish?

Also, just got this trade to a tentative conclusion, and neither my partner nor I are entirely sure if it's fair. Are there any item experts lurking out there who could give some good advice? If not I'll comb through the item equivalency guide and see what I can cobble together : )

Thank you so much, as always!

TT

Second and first opinions? : )

TT

I always say four rares of the same date to make it fair, but that's my opinion,

[starrine]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=29969715&userid=56647&signature=jvj87amlWQ7JXfW6hWDU4w

Is this fair? o.o

[BeaztVibe]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=29969715&userid=56647&signature=jvj87amlWQ7JXfW6hWDU4w

Is this fair? o.o

unfair to you ^^ the advent is only worth 7ish mixed 09 rares so the seal and a 09 rare would be enough

[KittyKat~]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=29969715&userid=56647&signature=jvj87amlWQ7JXfW6hWDU4w

Is this fair? o.o

quite unfair to you~

[IndigoCat]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=29969715&userid=56647&signature=jvj87amlWQ7JXfW6hWDU4w

Is this fair? o.o

unfair to you by quite a bit. the seal pps dog and a 2009 rare should be enough. ^^