The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Kyar]

Raven dogs demand is out of the roof though, so getting someone to trade it for that amount is next to impossible. Take demand into mind

The raven dog is also extremely common for a store pet of its time. It was just rare for months after its release.
The rares list takes into account both rarity and demand.
Demand is what the person offering chooses they wish to pay to ensure that they get a certain pet. NOT what the pet owner wants to "demand" based on overpay other users got.

Edit:

How was this trade?

I would say unfair to you, but get another opinion :3

I'd say it looks okay. :) The 08 cat is worth a lot less than its date suggests because it was available to adopt for a long time. :)

[.SarahBear.]

Raven dogs demand is out of the roof though, so getting someone to trade it for that amount is next to impossible. Take demand into mind

It's not about demand. It's about rarity, and where it falls on the advent list with its actual worth.

Exactly. I only cancelled that trade because I'm not looking to trade the raven, but it was perfectly fine and actually pretty good of an offer if a trade down is what you want.

[fairyheart]

How was this trade?

I would say unfair to you, but get another opinion :3

Agreed.

[Nikki Amaranti]

Is this trade fair for me?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... rncB8NXi-w
I'm just wondering for future trades.
Also, who is willing to do a trade similar to this, my bulk trade for their raven dog or target dog?
Thanks for the help.

Unfair to you.

Very unfair to you.
The Raven Dog is only a 5th tier advent.

Your overpaying by somewhat a lot with your side.
The List factors in demand already. People are just adding on extra demand due to people willing to pay a lot.
Whatever overpay they offer, doesn't make the Raven worth that. It's a 5th tier advent, and it is worth a 5th Tier.

Edit: Ninja'd

How was this trade?

[center][size=85]It's about fair.
The 08' Very Rare Cat was available for a very long time, so it's around a 09' Very Rare as well.

[/size][/center]

[Kyar]

How was this trade?

I would say unfair to you, but get another opinion :3

Agreed.

I'd say it's fair. :) I answered on the last page but I think it got buried. The 08 VR was available to adopt for a very long time so it's not as rare as its date implies.

[.SarahBear.]

I'd say it's fair. I answered on the last page but I think it got buried. The 08 VR was available to adopt for a very long time so it's not as rare as its date implies.

I agree. I stared at that one for the longest time and couldn't find anything unfair.

[Sonmi-451]

I'd say it's fair. I answered on the last page but I think it got buried. The 08 VR was available to adopt for a very long time so it's not as rare as its date implies.

I agree. I stared at that one for the longest time and couldn't find anything unfair.

Agreed as well; the trade looks fair to me.

[fairyheart]

fair? if not what can be added/removed. Thanks in advance

[dylanobrien]

fair? if not what can be added/removed. Thanks in advance

unfair to them ^^

[Kyar]

fair? if not what can be added/removed. Thanks in advance

I'm not quite sure what the store pets add up to together but I do believe that it's unfair to them. You may want another opinion though - I really can't remember those store pet values right now lol.