The "is this a fair trade?" thread [notice 2nd post]

[bookworm.]

PLEASE HELP!

Okay, this is the trade offer I received: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... KnK01Rkkgg

Two of the pets they offered aren't on my wishlist, and one that is on my wishlist, I don't really want as much as some of their other pets. I would keep the cat they offered and replace the other three pets with another 2013 cat from the same litter, a 2012 pink rose dog, and a purple Slumber Party dream dog. Would that be a fair trade? If not, why?

It's fair like it is.

[Laark]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=29310198&userid=259920&signature=Dw42ZSvGyy-HxTA6b-yKjw



fair?

Unfair to them, I believe.

how can I make it fair? :3 and can I get a second opinion?

[zee99]

Fair? Just double checking. Thanks

[Yoru-Sasayaki]

PLEASE HELP!

Okay, this is the trade offer I received: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... KnK01Rkkgg

Two of the pets they offered aren't on my wishlist, and one that is on my wishlist, I don't really want as much as some of their other pets. I would keep the cat they offered and replace the other three pets with another 2013 cat from the same litter, a 2012 pink rose dog, and a purple Slumber Party dream dog. Would that be a fair trade? If not, why?

It's fair like it is.

You mean like how they put it? That wasn't what I was asking, though. ^^; I wanted to know if my counter-offer would be fair. I already know I don't like their offer.

[BeaztVibe]

Would it be worth auctioning a TWA? I have two trades sitting for it and both are slight over pay but i am wondering
Also is this fair? :3 including demand for the UR 09 I think its a Gearback

The trade is unfair to you. ^^

thank you <3 what could i change to make it fair?

[Ms. Procrastination]

Fair? Just double checking. Thanks

I towould liketo know the answer as I am involed

[painted.]

Is this fair? Not sure how much bottom tier advents go for >.<

[painted.]

Fair? Just double checking. Thanks

I towould liketo know the answer as I am involed

Unfair to the C$

[Aethyrr]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 6KFJPsMkzQ

Is this fair?

[zee99]

Fair? Just double checking. Thanks

I towould liketo know the answer as I am involed

Unfair to the C$

Thank you ^^