The "is this a fair trade?" thread [notice 2nd post]

[Mako.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=28650048&userid=377229&signature=DaXK9rvDQ4YNcwsbFg1OHQ
I was told this was unfair to me. But, I was just messages saying it was fair to both sides. This message was from the bidder. Is it fair, or not fair? Thanks!

That is unfair to you, although i'm not 100% sure on the value of the items, so get another opinion.

[dunsparce]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=28618322&userid=1409&signature=KZYjqrKL4-8Z_LP_K4SOGg

What should be added to the top?

[motheroffurbies]

I already know that this trade is unfair to me, but what needs to be added ?
*click*

and I have two more trades for which I need to know how fair they are ^^
1. *click*
2. *click*

[KayKayKoala]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=28529604&userid=386911&signature=KdNXEJowpBe4Y4bzDq8xJg

Is this fair?
I am the one who would be giving the blue sorbet bun

[jovana97]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=28529604&userid=386911&signature=KdNXEJowpBe4Y4bzDq8xJg

Is this fair?
I am the one who would be giving the blue sorbet bun

It's slightly unfair to you,add early '09 uncommon or late '09 rare to their side and it should be ok. :]

[Appleberry Crumble]

How fair/unfair is this trade? If it's not, would it be fair if it was changed to just the rats being swapped?

[Mako.]

How fair/unfair is this trade? If it's not, would it be fair if it was changed to just the rats being swapped?

Unfair to you, if it was only the rats being swapped, then that would be fair.

[Derse&Prospit]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=28650048&userid=377229&signature=DaXK9rvDQ4YNcwsbFg1OHQ
I was told this was unfair to me. But, I was just messages saying it was fair to both sides. This message was from the bidder. Is it fair, or not fair? Thanks!

That is unfair to you, although i'm not 100% sure on the value of the items, so get another opinion.

Thank you! Can I get another opinion? Thanks!

[Jaskiest]

Pink Striped September = Green Liontail + Red Malk Dragon
Would that be fair? If not, what would be fair for the Green Liontail and Red Malk Dragon?
Thanks!

Anyone know about this one?
Thanks again!

[Lonewolf199152]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... EnppdJskaA
Not sure about this trade....
Im really interested in the pps dog...though not sure i would trade my dragon for just it...
Any opinions on it? Is this even fair? I am unsure due to the item placed in the trade...