The "is this a fair trade?" thread [notice 2nd post]

[love miccado]

I need a second opinion.
Are the following examples underpay, overpay, or equal to the Devil/Blood PPS?
All Punk dogs + a Raven dog
All Androids + a Raven dog
Three Punk dogs + July Lion + Raven dog
Three Punk dogs + Marionette + Purple Sleipnir + Raven Dog

List wise i would say some of them would be fair, but demand wise, i dont think that you can have on of this....
The Punk Dogs have good Demand and the Raven goes at the Moment for high September or low Main List Pets.

But get another Opinion, i would not give fals advice.

[Kyar]

I need a second opinion.
Are the following examples underpay, overpay, or equal to the Devil/Blood PPS?
All Punk dogs + a Raven dog
All Androids + a Raven dog
Three Punk dogs + July Lion + Raven dog
Three Punk dogs + Marionette + Purple Sleipnir + Raven Dog

List wise i would say some of them would be fair, but demand wise, i dont think that you can have on of this....
The Punk Dogs have good Demand and the Raven goes at the Moment for high September or low Main List Pets.

But get another Opinion, i would not give fals advice.

Every single one of those trades is unfair to the blood PPS going by the list. The list actually already does factor in demand. The raven was on a high peak as far as demand goes a few months ago but it's died down. A lot. Besides - it never went for main list pets. Maybe someone bid a main list in an auction but it didn't consistently "go" for that much. The closest of all of those would probably be the last one but again - none are fair to the PPS.

I think this is unfair, but correct me if I'm wrong what should they add/remove?

Fair demand wise?

I won't answer the second because it's my trade and I always feel weird commenting on them but the first one is unfair to you by more than a non. :)

[Solloby]

How far off fair is this? They can add July Lioness.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... HuMmYOinog

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... qpUg_l0GyA

[Kyar]

How far off fair is this? They can add July Lioness.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... HuMmYOinog

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... qpUg_l0GyA

The first one is unfair to you by around a coontail or so. :)
The second looks unfair to them - but you may want another opinion. :)

[Mistyleap]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... eSRdZEaeOw
Help!

[FoxerOwl]

Brown Sleipner + Purple Sleipner = Pink Flop-Eared September?

If not, what should I add/remove?

[Kyar]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=27546453&userid=398061&signature=FvnyR9UpZPSbeSRdZEaeOw
Help!

Looks unfair to them. :) You'll probably want another opinion though - I don't do a lot of warrior cat trading. :)

Brown Sleipner + Purple Sleipner = Pink Flop-Eared September?

If not, what should I add/remove?

The sleipnirs together would be worth a grinner - the floppy eared september is worth three grinners. :)
Having the sleipnirs as a set might bring in a little more for demand - and they tend to do alright anyway - so I wouldn't be SHOCKED to see it happen but it's quite unfair to the september dog. :)

[FoxerOwl]

Brown Sleipner + Purple Sleipner = Pink Flop-Eared September?

If not, what should I add/remove?

The sleipnirs together would be worth a grinner - the floppy eared september is worth three grinners.
Having the sleipnirs as a set might bring in a little more for demand - and they tend to do alright anyway - so I wouldn't be SHOCKED to see it happen but it's quite unfair to the september dog.

Hmm, what if I added both of Tess' husky dogs? c:

If that doesn't do it, which tier would make it fair with the Sleipnirs and huskies?

EDIT: Oh gosh three grinners? .___. Well I'm mainly looking for advent quantity, what could I add with the two sets mentioned above?

[vvoland]

Line Tribal + Gearback Tribal + Spotted Tribal = ?

Thanks <3

[Solloby]

Thanks Kyar <3

What do I have to add to Spotted Tribal for a Blue Toxic & Yellow Sorbet?