The "is this a fair trade?" thread [notice 2nd post]

[~Mia~]

Please I need a quick reply, thanks

[*Summer Frost*]

Please I need a quick reply, thanks

I might say you are overpaying. Especially because you have a couple '08s in there. But please do get a second opinion.

[~Mia~]

Please I need a quick reply, thanks

I might say you are overpaying. Especially because you have a couple '08s in there. But please do get a second opinion.

okay, should I remove the GWJ?

[Reb]

Please I need a quick reply, thanks

I might say you are overpaying. Especially because you have a couple '08s in there. But please do get a second opinion.

okay, should I remove the GWJ?

You are overpaying greatly, rarity wise.
The UR Cucumber is already higher than the Coontail, alone.
Although if you base the UR Cucumbers worse as around a Non (Which is what they go for nowadays),
then it is still overpay on your half. ^^

[PepperSlushy]

Please I need a quick reply, thanks

I might say you are overpaying. Especially because you have a couple '08s in there. But please do get a second opinion.

okay, should I remove the GWJ?

WAY OVERPAYING, YOU OFFERED LIKE 08 VERY RARES, 09 VERY RARES A COUPLE OF RARES AND AN OMG SO RARE!!!!!! THAT SOULD BE GOOD FOR FIVE OF THEM!!!! please excuse me. *gets drink of water* AND YA, NOT FARE. SO CANCEL(

[Bast]

What would make this trade fair? Keeping red cattledog in trade.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 0GsRjp9d8Q

A Eat me would make this fair.
If you close out the Sunback Nick and the Nick Tox.

I somewhat understood that?? How fair/unfair is it to the cerb?

[melody.]

Hello. :3
I really want to accept this but I'm ot sure- is it fair to them? c:
Thankyou for your time. ^-^

Unfair to the Red Fronted Holly Dog

Thankyou, any other opinion? c:

[~Mia~]

Please I need a quick reply, thanks

okay thank you all who helped!!

[Merlin's Heir]

Is this fair? *sigh* C$...

Please help me out quickly, I want to find out before they cancel the trade or something.

I think it's unfair to you, not sure.

I agree. If you value the UR Flower Pot at a Non, then the C$ value would need to add up to 1000 C$, and that only adds up to 975 C$ c: Though I may warn you, C$ is pretty hard to trade for List Pets (Quite a few people won't take C$ for their List Pets), if that was your intention for it.
In case I'm a bit off at judging the UR Pot's value, you may also want a third opinion ^^;

Thanks. Third opinion, anyone?

[Bast]

What would make this trade fair? Keeping red cattledog in trade.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 0GsRjp9d8Q

A Eat me would make this fair.
If you close out the Sunback Nick and the Nick Tox.

I somewhat understood that?? How fair/unfair is it to the cerb?