The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [notice 2nd post]

[Butterfly~kitten]

Umm.. new thread please!

[daybreak.]

Can anyone with experience of main list trades help me with this? I believe the first is amazing, second is unfair to me perhaps by demand? I've heard of the cucumbers going for just a GWJ plus a UR ice cat. Please consider demand (yes the rares list takes in demand but it does fluctuate! Also many cucumbers are re-released I think?)

1. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... owu8v6YUEA
2. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 3YepXbfRBg
3. Also how easy is it to trade for UR ice cats and nonballoons? If I trade them I want to get another two back soon. Thank you so much!

Both trades are rather unfair to the other person if you go off the Rares List. I'd personally take the first.
I honestly don't know how hard it's to get a nonballoon but there's a lot of people trading UR Ice Cats right now, so I expect that would be easy if you have the right fodder.

[Puddin_Pie]

Hi,

Is this fair?

[daybreak.]

Hi,

Is this fair?

No Puddin, that's rather unfair to you ;3
The Wolf PPS is on the Main List.

[Fat Unicorn]

New Thread!

Please post there instead.

[heartsong]

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=26831968&userid=20172&signature=WRrOrJbgNfG7vlxdIhmAMw

[Wolvefine]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... xWmBKHMlGA

Fair?

[Naira]

Um, Guys. A little bit above your posts, Fat Unicorn has posted the new thread, so I suggest you ask there. C:

[TaroMisaki]

Hey, could anyone tell me if this trade would be fair or not?
If it's not it would be very nice if you could tell me what should be added~

[Pi.]

Hey, could anyone tell me if this trade would be fair or not?
If it's not it would be very nice if you could tell me what should be added~

There is a new thread. Please read the posts above.