The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [notice 2nd post]

[Veja]

How is this? What should be added/removed? ^^

They overpaid.

Please don't try to help people here when you do not know what you are talking about. It is unfair to the Devil PPS side.

I have no idea... Help?

Unfair to you.

Okay. What should i add? I would prefer to add more C$.

I'm not really sure C$-wise on this one.

[chernobyl]

I just traded an August PPS lion for a Purple Star Bob tail. Was that a good trade? Is it unfair to anyone?

[Contra23]

Hello, is this a fair trade? I'm thinking it's overpay on my side but I'm not completely sure so any help would be much appreciated! Thank you.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... BzRLrL-xww

[resque]

I just traded an August PPS lion for a Purple Star Bob tail. Was that a good trade? Is it unfair to anyone?

It was unfair to the Purple Star Bob tail.

[plutonian]

I just traded an August PPS lion for a Purple Star Bob tail. Was that a good trade? Is it unfair to anyone?

It was unfair to the Purple Star Bob tail.

Yes I agree. Very unfair to the Purple Star Bob tail...

[Kyar]

Hello, is this a fair trade? I'm thinking it's overpay on my side but I'm not completely sure so any help would be much appreciated! Thank you.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... BzRLrL-xww

I believe you're overpaying yes - although not by a whole lot. Personally I would take it because as far as I am aware it can be very difficult to trade off the zombie/roadkill ponies. That being said my knowledge is limited to before the lineart change so if you have not had trouble finding people who have interest in it then demand may no longer be so much of an issue. :) Either way I think taking off 1-2 store pets from your side would be more fair. :)

[plutonian]

Hello, is this a fair trade? I'm thinking it's overpay on my side but I'm not completely sure so any help would be much appreciated! Thank you.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... BzRLrL-xww

I'm sure it should a bit unfair to them. They are overpaying. The blood dog is on the advent list. The pony you own is on the advent list too though. But 3 tiers lower. The store pets might fill the difference but maybe not. So it should be fair or they are overpaying. ^_^

[Kyar]

Hello, is this a fair trade? I'm thinking it's overpay on my side but I'm not completely sure so any help would be much appreciated! Thank you.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... BzRLrL-xww

I'm sure it should a bit unfair to them. They are overpaying. The blood dog is on the advent list. The pony you own is on the advent list too though. But 3 tiers lower. The store pets might fill the difference but maybe not. So it should be fair or they are overpaying. ^_^

The gap between each line is around an 09 uncommon/rare. I most lines are closer to a rare and in this case I do (personally) believe it more than covers the gap. :)
If you're not sure if it covers the gap though you probably shouldn't start off your post by saying it's unfair to them. I understand that you were debating it but if you decided at the end that it is closer to fair you could always go back and delete the part where you said you thought they were overpaying. :) It just could be a little confusing for someone trying to follow your post.

[ThisIsGospel1]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 0gEAg2SUlA c:

[wingsofsilver]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=26759298&userid=381352&signature=daqEDv_d1i8u0gEAg2SUlA c:

Very unfair to them.