The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [notice 2nd post]

[-TheBigBlueBear-]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=26731144&userid=176754&signature=1zFlao_xETVEOpQU_uJSEQ

Is this fair ? If not by how much ?

Unfair to you. The gap between the Spotted Tribal and the GWJ is only a UR apple, I believe.

Don't give false information. The gap is at least two sorbs.

Actually this is also false.
A GWJ Is worth about two sorbs [any color] and an UR Apple.
The Spotted Tribal alone is more than one sorbet. The gearback + a dark leo is approximately worth another sorbet based on the rough draft of the breakdown for the rares list so the Gearback + A spotted tribal is enough to bridge the gap and is at least two sorbets when you add them together.

If you add the two together plus the C$ It's probably about fair.
Since from my knowledge about 75 C$ is about a mid advent [correct? If not someone feel free to correct me ^^"]
Demand of all the dogs isn't that great from what I've seen.

Please get another opinion though just in case.
- Cole

[Lake Petal]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=26735740&userid=341938&signature=csL93b1VbRToYR6UTGIXsw

Fair? Thanks

Unfair to them
You're asking for too much.

Hell, thats the worst trade i've ever seen^^
You want 22 Very rares, and a lot of other special pets, for just one Very Rare?
NOPE, thats unfair

Don't give false information. Although I agree it is slightly overpay, it is not THAT much, seeing as it is on the advent list, and a lot higher then the scarf.

[Pirate Spawn]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=26735637&userid=384553&signature=uG4zzfNw7wSU5cdFuRdXkw
Is this fair? Thanks in advance.

[Lake Petal]

-Cole Stargazer- : I got my gaps mixed again.. Damn. Sorry!

[Silverwulfess]

[quote=

Is this fair? Thanks in advance!

[/quote]

[dontdrinkthepoison]

I need some advice on the following trade. I admit I have very little interest in a couple of these pets, but I am not sure how to edit it so that it is fair to both of us.

Any suggestions/advice/ or comments are appreciated.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=26734187&userid=156055&signature=g2WYT9qLJZbC3yHsFZnVJA

Unfair to them

But if I traded for just the dog, would it be unfair to me?
There is a two year difference but it is Uncommon versus Rare Halloween pet.

[&& echo;]

how does this look?
please, only reply if you actually know what the
items are worth and know what you're talking about.

i think it's fair, but i want someone
else's opinion. c:

[psychodrama]

Any ideas what this is worth? thanks in advance!

[-TheBigBlueBear-]

Is this fair? Thanks in advance!

I don't want to guarantee anything because I browsed some conversations here and on the Rares list thread and couldn't really find anything on the 12 UR Cat.
I remember awhile back hearing here that the 12 UR Cat was worth between a balloon dog/Wood wing to a Green/Yellow Toxic.
I'm not sure where you value it in according to what it's currently at since I cannot find any data from reliable sources to back me up.

From everything else it appears that it would be unfair to the Red Toxic though.
The Gap between the Yellow/Green toxic to the red toxic is about a blue rose + a Skelly PPS.
From what I see the Pink Patchy + The Sunjewel Bunny is about a blue rose, possibly higher but not to the main list.
If so it's certainly not to the Skelly PPS.
So Even if you value the 12 UR Cat as a toxic it'd still be unfair to the Red toxic.
Please get a second opinion from someone else as well just in case.

But from everything I know that's my advice.



how does this look?
please, only reply if you actually know what the
items are worth and know what you're talking about.

I think it's fair, but I want someone
else's opinion. c:


Sorry for changing your coding ^^" <3 It's late here.
I'm looking at the current item guide as my lead since unfortunately I'm not entirely sure based on item demand and such.
But based on the item guides list the angel wings are worth an October/November '08 rare so there's 4 of those already.
A mid advent is worth 7 early [Jan - March] '09 Rares.
Each line is different by an '09 rare.

So if you go down, the snowflake lion is about 7 '09 rares. [early from what I know]
So I'm thinking it's unfair to them already considering what the items are worth [just the pocky and angel wings alone]
Don't take my advice completely considering the Item Guide is being remade [I don't know if that includes item worth or just lay out]

But it looks unfair to them if anything ^^" <3

Make sure to always get second opinions from reliable sources though as Items are not my strong point ^^"
- Cole

[Felix2]

What could be added to this trade to make it fair?
Thanks in advance!
-Felix