The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [notice 2nd post]

[Dragonborn Comes]

joker + sorbet = non jewel?

[lucky333123]

Is this fair? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... dUba9eH3_g Does re releasing a pet lower it's value? That pet was originally a 09' rare but technically that pet is as 12' rare.

It is still an '09 rare and should be considered as such. Some members don't value re-releases as much, but they are still the same creature and should tech. have the same value.

I'm not sure if it is fair or not, sorry.

Is this trade fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ac2GcW6aGA

Thanks in advance!

[Ashki]

joker + sorbet = non jewel?

Unfair to the non jewel, rarity wise. Demand wise, if joker's are going for nons, unfair to the joker.

[Kex.]

Is this fair? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... dUba9eH3_g Does re releasing a pet lower it's value? That pet was originally a 09' rare but technically that pet is as 12' rare.

It is still an '09 rare and should be considered as such. Some members don't value re-releases as much, but they are still the same creature and should tech. have the same value.

I'm not sure if it is fair or not, sorry.

Is this trade fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ac2GcW6aGA

Thanks in advance!

Agreed, the fact that it's a re-release does not change the pets real value in any bit.
And that trade is fair, the eggs are worth an early '10 uncommon each.

[Krista Lenz]

Could someone please tell me if this is fair?

Thanks for any help! ^.^

[Ashki]

Are Red-X PPS fairly easy to trade? And is this close to fair?

The trade is unfair to them. And I'm not too sure about the demand of the red x pps.

[lucky333123]

Is this fair? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... dUba9eH3_g Does re releasing a pet lower it's value? That pet was originally a 09' rare but technically that pet is as 12' rare.

It is still an '09 rare and should be considered as such. Some members don't value re-releases as much, but they are still the same creature and should tech. have the same value.

I'm not sure if it is fair or not, sorry.

Is this trade fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ac2GcW6aGA

Thanks in advance!

Agreed, the fact that it's a re-release does not change the pets real value in any bit.
And that trade is fair, the eggs are worth an early '10 uncommon each.

[/quote]

Thanks I thought the trade was fair, but another member kept on telling me they were worth an '09 each so I just wanted to double check.

[Krist Fullmetal]

Was This Trade Fair
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... eviJuUeifQ

[Krista Lenz]

Could someone please tell me if this is fair?

Thanks for any help! ^.^

[Kex.]

Thanks I thought the trade was fair, but another member kept on telling me they were worth an '09 each so I just wanted to double check.

Nope, the earlier eggs are worth an 09 rare each. The ones from 2009.
These are from 2010.