The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [notice pg. 740]

[BubbleAndFizz]

Winged Wood Angel + Blood dog =

Depends on which blood litter dog

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=26350206&userid=194900&signature=AICqgVEfcQubmc11rRsdyw

Fair? C:

Unfair to you

Thanks!

[KisaWolfz]

Winged Wood Angel + Blood dog =

Depends on which blood litter dog

Flop Eared (advent)

[Kevinsaurus]

Is this fair? If not, what needs to be added/taken off? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... TxlmpoDO5Q

Very unfair to you, the 2nd gen alone is a fair swap

Winged Wood Angel + Blood dog =

Depends on which blood litter dog

Flop Eared (advent)

There's no single pet that's technically worth a WWA + an advent level pet so my only answer is a balloon/WWA level pet plus another pet of equal tier value to the blood, if you were trying to get a 1-pet answer. If you add a couple of mid advents to that, it'd be roughly worth an RBM though.

[sunshine12789]

Is this trade/bid fair?: Fair??
Thanks!

I think I disagree, I think sunshine's overpaying.
Let's see:

sunshine's side:..................................other person's side:
Nonballoon (Main List)........................Blue Sorbet (ML)
Speckled Rat (ML)...............................Cake Dog (SL)
Blue UR Cat (ML)................................ Red Dragon (SL)
??? Rat (SL)..........................................Blue Flower Dog (AL)
..........................................................Android (AL)
..........................................................Android (AL)
4 2009 R............................................2 2020 VR
etc.....................................................2 2011 VR

She has many more main list, or what did I miss?

Okay I am kind of confused since some people are saying unfair and then some people are saying overpaying. This person does make a point..what do you think?

[BubbleAndFizz]

Is this trade/bid fair?: Fair??
Thanks!

I think I disagree, I think sunshine's overpaying.
Let's see:

sunshine's side:..................................other person's side:
Nonballoon (Main List)........................Blue Sorbet (ML)
Speckled Rat (ML)...............................Cake Dog (SL)
Blue UR Cat (ML)................................ Red Dragon (SL)
??? Rat (SL)..........................................Blue Flower Dog (AL)
..........................................................Android (AL)
..........................................................Android (AL)
4 2009 R............................................2 2020 VR
etc.....................................................2 2011 VR

She has many more main list, or what did I miss?

Okay I am kind of confused since some people are saying unfair and then some people are saying overpaying. This person does make a point..what do you think?

I agree.

[Rapid Paranoia]

Is this fair? If not, what needs to be added/taken off? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... TxlmpoDO5Q

Very unfair to you, the 2nd gen alone is a fair swap

I'm really confused..Isn't the cat from 2008 though? Wouldn't that be unfair?

[hiatus.]

I'm really confused..which is the 2nd gen?

just edit your side to only have the first dog you see on the bottom, with the red 2nd gen text.

[Ashki]

Is this trade/bid fair?: Fair??
Thanks! :D

I think I disagree, I think sunshine's overpaying.
Let's see:

sunshine's side:..................................other person's side:
Nonballoon (Main List)........................Blue Sorbet (ML)
Speckled Rat (ML)...............................Cake Dog (SL)
Blue UR Cat (ML)................................ Red Dragon (SL)
??? Rat (SL)..........................................Blue Flower Dog (AL)
..........................................................Android (AL)
..........................................................Android (AL)
4 2009 R............................................2 2020 VR
etc.....................................................2 2011 VR

She has many more main list, or what did I miss?

Okay I am kind of confused since some people are saying unfair and then some people are saying overpaying. This person does make a point..what do you think?

There is no mainlist rat on sunshine's side...? I would say unfair to the blue sorbet side, still.

[daybreak.]

I'm really confused..which is the 2nd gen?

The one that says 2Gen in red letters on it's image ;3

[Rapid Paranoia]

I'm really confused..which is the 2nd gen?

The one that says 2Gen in red letters on it's image ;3

Ohh, but isn't the cat from 2008? Wouldn't that make it unfair to them?