The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [notice pg. 740]

[daybreak.]

Bid 1

Bid 2

Can't decide which one's better, although i'm leaning towards the 2nd one slightly. My trade knowledge sucks, so i'm not good with things like this. ;-; I might just tie them both first... idk.

Opinions? Thanks~

First on is best

No but see, let's compare:
First...........................................Second
1 2008 Oct (rare)........................1 2008 Oct (VR)
1 2008 Nov (rare).......................1 2008 Nov (rare)
1 2008 Advent (VR)....................1 2008 Advent (VR)
1 2008 Advent (rare)..................1 2008 Advent (VR)
2 2009 (VR)................................2 2009 (VR)
1 2010 (VR).............................
2 2010 (VR).............................

The difference between the more valuable pets from 2008 in the second trade (2008 Oct & 2008 Advent) and the pets from these same months but of a lesser value on the first, would outweigh the three 2010 VR pets included in the first bid but absent in the second, in my opinion.

[jujuwawa]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=26260821&userid=376922&signature=AX3-TNpRl32cQg4Up8jSUQ

Is this fair? Thanks in advance
NTN

I'd say it's slightly unfair to the blue sorb. A blue sorbet is worth two green/yellow toxics. and I don't think the two advent list bunnies makes up completely for the gap between the non balloon and the toxic.

Yes, you're right. Technically the bottom would need to add another low September List. But the demand for the Blue Sorb is much worse than it is for the Nonballoon which makes it about equal.

[Witchie]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... QPJmK26GzQ
Fair or not?
What must I/they add to make it fair?

[ponder;]

fair?

[Fusselsturm]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... y8tQA6Brog is this one fair? :O

[Alpha She-Wolf]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=26260315&userid=417602&signature=dZd6kC80G47yy8tQA6Brog is this one fair? :O

I'd say not.

[Fusselsturm]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=26260315&userid=417602&signature=dZd6kC80G47yy8tQA6Brog is this one fair? :O

I'd say not.

okay ty what would be okay? some rares from 2010 or must it be a very rare 2010?

[Celozon]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=26260315&userid=417602&signature=dZd6kC80G47yy8tQA6Brog is this one fair? :O

I'd say not.

If you are going to answer questions please be specific. Just saying it is not fair does not tell us who it is unfair to, and thus is not helpful.
Unfair to them.

fair?

Unfair to them.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=26261002&userid=349941&signature=Y0N6PFEH5gJLQPJmK26GzQ
Fair or not?
What must I/they add to make it fair?

It is unfair to you by about a mid advent.

[Felix2]

Is this fair?I'm not great on mass trades and wanted to make sure it was at least fair to the other person. Thanks in advance!

[Witchie]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=26261002&userid=349941&signature=Y0N6PFEH5gJLQPJmK26GzQ
Fair or not?
What must I/they add to make it fair?

It is unfair to you by about a mid advent.

Thanks and this?
Fair or not?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... TBWc6MyMYg