The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [notice pg. 457]

[Sanivisu]

Is this really an overpay for my full set?
Because I doubt...
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... F2ohpW9tzA

as far as i can tell, yes it is.

Okay thanks. Second opinion would be nice.

[Noel]

Is this really an overpay for my full set?
Because I doubt...
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... F2ohpW9tzA

Yes, it is. ^^ At their best, store pets go for a '09 rare each. That's a great deal.

[blackberrycandy]

Is this really an overpay for my full set?
Because I doubt...
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... F2ohpW9tzA

as far as i can tell, yes it is.

Agreed. Each one is only worth an 09 rare c:

[D'Tani]

Is this fair?

[Bast]

What should I remove from their side to make if fair to my Nick sunback horse?? Or if still unfair by how much?? I'm planning on keeping the chinese new year pets.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... DHBr1i9KeA

The koi alone with a bunch of CNYs would be fine.

Thank you.

[Kevinsaurus]

Is this really an overpay for my full set?
Because I doubt...
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... F2ohpW9tzA

It's a lot of overpay on their part, each is worth an early '09 rare (to clarify, they're worth "earlies", not just any '09 rare)

I have two new bids. ^^
First bid and the second.
(People apparently can't follow rules and added hoard pets, so the tiger-designed pets and the 2013 dogs from this month don't count in the first bid.) What do both of them need to add? Thanks in advance. <3

1) Add a BEG + high sept / low main to their side
2) Add a dogtag + low toxic to their side

Is this fair?

Wrong link

[blackberrycandy]

Is this fair?

Wrong link c:

[JaiBrooksForever<3]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... xbdFGC68fQ
Is this a fair trade???? They offered a very rare horse or rat but I'm not sure, I suggested the horse but....is this fair?

[blackberrycandy]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=25214625&userid=377912&signature=WVBgsWQFoixWxbdFGC68fQ
Is this a fair trade???? They offered a very rare horse or rat but I'm not sure, I suggested the horse but....is this fair?

Going by 3 month rule, unfair to you c:

[Patch.]

I have two new bids. ^^
First bid and the second.
(People apparently can't follow rules and added hoard pets, so the tiger-designed pets and the 2013 dogs from this month don't count in the first bid.) What do both of them need to add? Thanks in advance. <3

1) Add a BEG + high sept / low main to their side
2) Add a dogtag + low toxic to their side

Thank you. <3