The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [rule about quoting!]

[Sage14]

What can i add if unfair to them?

possibly slight underpay

...what can i add is what i asked...

[Reb]

Is this trade or this trade fair?
Of the two, which is the better deal?
If one is unfair, what needs to be added?

Thanks,
- Phenomenon cx

I would say the second one is fair. If not slightly underpay? (Not sure on the where the UR Cat stands exactly)
And the first trade is overpaying for sure, since the UR butter bun is two gaps above already.
Get a second opinion on the second trade, though ^^

cx Okay, thanks. Yeah, I'm unsure about the UR cat's value. The demand has decreased quite a bit, but that doesn't mean it still isn't valuable.

And... with the above two trades, how is this trade?
I like the Rose PPS and the Drink Me dog, but compared to the other two trades, where would this one place?

Thanks,
- Phenomenon c:

If you are ranking them, that would come last for sure.

The Rose PPS is on the bottom of the list, and those other pets don't scrape off much gap for it to be fair.

[phenomenon]

If you are ranking them, that would come last for sure.

The Rose PPS is on the bottom of the list, and those other pets don't scrape off much gap for it to be fair.

Alright, great. c: Thanks for your help. ^-^

I'll wait for a second opinion on the first two trades then. cx
- Phenomenon

[Reb]

If you are ranking them, that would come last for sure.

The Rose PPS is on the bottom of the list, and those other pets don't scrape off much gap for it to be fair.

Alright, great. c: Thanks for your help. ^-^

I'll wait for a second opinion on the first two trades then. cx
- Phenomenon

No problem!

[wingsofsilver]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=24773561&userid=309172&signature=M14rGwhxcqps_DQiZWKcCw

Fair? Or what needs to be added? Plushie is worth an early 09 rare, just fyi.

Looks unfair to them ^^

Alrighty. What should I add to make it fair?

[Sage14]

What can i add if unfair to them?

[saorsa-]

If you are ranking them, that would come last for sure.

The Rose PPS is on the bottom of the list, and those other pets don't scrape off much gap for it to be fair.

Alright, great. c: Thanks for your help. ^-^

I'll wait for a second opinion on the first two trades then. cx
- Phenomenon

Going on what I've read around here and on other threads, the cat is going for a balloon dog - low toxic.

[siilence]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... _DQiZWKcCw

Fair? Or what needs to be added? Plushie is worth an early 09 rare, just fyi.

Alrighty. What should I add to make it fair?

Around two 09 rares c:

[Shadowflight13]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=24773736&userid=371656&signature=rIfPm17QX18X2BVmpQV8Uw

Is this trade fair? If not, what can I do to make it fair? Thanks a billion!

[ThatCoffeeBoi]

Fair? I am thinking not... Correct me if I am wrong? c:
Thanks in advance for any help~ ^^