The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [rule about quoting!]

[Shego]

1. What needs to be added?

2. Is this fair?

1. Dont know

2. I Think it is fair

Second opinions?

both unfair to you

[phoebe11850]

Thanks ^^ So what needs to be added?

1. What needs to be added?

2. What needs to be added/taken off?

[Kecko]

A 2012 Store Pet for a 2010 Rare? That's fair in general isn't it?

[Weiss Schnee]

Could I get some advice on these?
One {Pretty sure it's unfair to me}
Two
Three
If they're unfair, what would need to be added?
Experienced traders only, please. ^^
Thank you in advance!

[MintyMist]

I know that this trade is probably technically unfair to them but I wasn't sure demand wise.

demand wise it is fair

[maleficent.]

fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... UVgb-yZS0A

[Alex ツ]

Would it be a fair trade if:
This for this
CS Birthday Dog (April.2009/rare) for Staff Birthday Shima Luan Fox (September.2009/rare)
?? o:
If not what needs to be added?
Thanks in advance~

[polerberr]

So I got this trade from a COPPA'd user. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=24575052&userid=212595&signature=7zKffA4OWb3-HZl7zISUTw

I don't want to trade one of those cats and I figured the trade was unfair anyways. I cancelled the trade giving some advice to save that dog for an older rare cat they wanted (it looked like this user was collecting cats when I checked out her pets), and gave her a free wl cat I had a spare of. The trade was accepted, but right after the user sent me the same trade again, which is the one in the URL. Is it even a fair trade? If so, I might just trade if I can replace the NEFT cat, but I don't want to cheat some kid out of a rare '09 dog if they can get something better out of it.

[LiveForever]

How fair is this looking ?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 9xIBvxAnAA
Thank you

[Calix]

A 2012 Store Pet for a 2010 Rare? That's fair in general isn't it?

Yep, that's the usual rate. Depends on the demand and species of both, but generally that should be fair.

Could I get some advice on these?
One {Pretty sure it's unfair to me}
Two
Three
If they're unfair, what would need to be added?
Experienced traders only, please. ^^
Thank you in advance!

1. Very unfair to you.
2. Also very unfair to you.
3. I don't have the rares list open, but I believe that's fair? Get another (less lazy) opinion.

fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... UVgb-yZS0A

Unfair to them.

Would it be a fair trade if:
This for this
CS Birthday Dog (April.2009/rare) for Staff Birthday Shima Luan Fox (September.2009/rare)
?? o:
If not what needs to be added?
Thanks in advance~

Almost fair, usually pets within three months of eachother that are the same rarity can do a straight swap, but they're 5 months apart. Maybe just add a couple of 2012-2013 pets.

So I got this trade from a COPPA'd user. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=24575052&userid=212595&signature=7zKffA4OWb3-HZl7zISUTw

I don't want to trade one of those cats and I figured the trade was unfair anyways. I cancelled the trade giving some advice to save that dog for an older rare cat they wanted (it looked like this user was collecting cats when I checked out her pets), and gave her a free wl cat I had a spare of. The trade was accepted, but right after the user sent me the same trade again, which is the one in the URL. Is it even a fair trade? If so, I might just trade if I can replace the NEFT cat, but I don't want to cheat some kid out of a rare '09 dog if they can get something better out of it.

Unfair to them. But if they seem to be insisting on doing a trade like that even if you told them it's unfair, you're not really cheating them out of it. Most kids don't give a darn about rarity anyways, haha.

How fair is this looking ?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 9xIBvxAnAA
Thank you

Definitely get another opinion, but I'd guess unfair to you. I know the ur cat was the most common ur out of the set, but I'm not sure where it's being valued on the list exactly.

---

Feel free to get second opinions on any advice I gave. I'm sleepy so it may be inaccurate.