The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [FTT Contest!]

[Umbrellas]

I have to disagree with you on that @~Cake Pops~. The first bid is an overpay, and the third isn't even fair to the grinner.

Well actually it is overpay. Just not as big an overpay as the first.

[aye;]

deand wise , got offer for a BA for my p - toxic. demand wise fair?

I've gotten purple toxic level pets offered for my BA before, but you can get one for less. It's a bit of a stretch, imo. I wouldn't take it personally; I'd add a bit to their side.

Truth is, Black Advents are worth exactly where they are on the Sept List... by rarity alone they are only worth a mid-advent... it is the demand that has them on the Sept List at all... meaning that when people demand even more it is like going into a store to buy a $400 TV and once they see how much you want it they decide you have to pay $800

[Nyan♪]

is a fair trade?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ZYI7X90SMA

I would say that it is unfair to them but please feel free to get a second opinion ^^

[pockypo]

Bid #2
Bid #10
Which bid is better for the Blue Grinner?

Second one is better technically

I would say the 1st one is fair. The purple grinner is worth the same as the blue grinner, so it would be a fair swap.

Thanks guys. x3
Any other opinions?

I thought that the first one might be better, since the Purple Grinner is technically rarer than the Blue since I believe it turned rare first, (I could be wrong on that), but I didn't know if all of the other rares in the other bid PLUS the low advent list pet would bring that up to the Grinner's worth?

[CelestialFrost]

Unfair to them
Unfair to you (unless one of those items is worth a lot)

Thanks.
How is it unfair though? Just wondering. :3
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 3ht0Rlde_w

[Umbrellas]

Bid #2
Bid #10
Which bid is better for the Blue Grinner?

Second one is better technically

I would say the 1st one is fair. The purple grinner is worth the same as the blue grinner, so it would be a fair swap.

Thanks guys. x3
Any other opinions?

I thought that the first one might be better, since the Purple Grinner is technically rarer than the Blue since I believe it turned rare first, (I could be wrong on that), but I didn't know if all of the other rares in the other bid PLUS the low advent list pet would bring that up to the Grinner's worth?

I believe all the Grinners are equal, the purple one just used to have more demand once upon a time. Now grinners don't really have good demand at all, so it isn't really important anymore.
The second one is the best. The rares would be overpay by themselves, as well as the mid advent added makes it a better trade.

[katsukeys]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... PPD5i05R4g
If I took the first rare dog away, would it be unfair for the PPS Pup?

[Umbrellas]

Unfair to them
Unfair to you (unless one of those items is worth a lot)

Thanks.
How is it unfair though? Just wondering. :3
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 3ht0Rlde_w

It's going to be hard to say until the pot is placed on the rareslist. Assuming it's roughly worth a non, it'd be unfair to you by a bit less than another Spotted Tribal level pet.

[.Secret.]

is a fair trade?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ZYI7X90SMA

Unfair to you on so many levels.

[heartsong]

Is this trade fair? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=24008298&userid=20172&signature=5e-A1oEdFCLkMf0OL4bfaA
I'm not the best with items and most of the stuff on the item guide is valued at the whole set rather than individual items

Thanks in advance