The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [FTT Contest!]

[Umbrellas]

How fair are these? What would make it fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... BCfbH8wJBg
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 3ht0Rlde_w
Thank you!

Unfair to them
Unfair to you (unless one of those items is worth a lot)

[cherrystarluv]

Fair? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=24009233&userid=54249&signature=_436NwsGK5GrxWKOn2ai5Q

no it is not if you want it to be fair by lists yes but the rarity then no

Highly unfair to the '12 UR Dog. They are going for Nons at the moment. Non Coons, Non Swirls, and Non Tags. They are over the big gap, and it takes at least 3 sorbets to get over it.
Hope this helps. C:

Thank you guys so much <3

[Umbrellas]

Bid #2
Bid #10
Which bid is better for the Blue Grinner?

Second one is better technically

I would say the 1st one is fair. The purple grinner is worth the same as the blue grinner, so it would be a fair swap.

First one is fair, but the second one is overpay.

[Aperture Science]

Which one is the most fair to me? Not sure which to accept..
|x|
|x|
|x|

i think the 3 one

Number 2

Thank you both! Other opinions?

1st one

conflicting opinions.. anyone else wanna help me out?

[tacocat.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... vEizKYYdbA

[Umbrellas]

-snip-
conflicting opinions.. anyone else wanna help me out?

first one is the best (with the pink striped sept)

[CSF]

Which one is the most fair to me? Not sure which to accept..
|x|
|x|
|x|

i think the 3 one

Number 2

Thank you both! Other opinions?

1st one

:lol: conflicting opinions.. anyone else wanna help me out?

I would say the first one

[Adonis]

deand wise , got offer for a BA for my p - toxic. demand wise fair?

[pockypo]

Bid #2
Bid #10
Which bid is better for the Blue Grinner?

Second one is better technically

I would say the 1st one is fair. The purple grinner is worth the same as the blue grinner, so it would be a fair swap.

Thanks guys. x3
Any other opinions?

I thought that the first one might be better, since the Purple Grinner is technically rarer than the Blue since I believe it turned rare first, (I could be wrong on that), but I didn't know if all of the other rares in the other bid PLUS the low advent list pet would bring that up to the Grinner's worth?

[aye;]

Which one is the most fair to me? Not sure which to accept..
|x|
|x|
|x|

The first one is the best. The Pink September is actually an overpay, for it is a couple spaces higher than the Grinner on the September List.