The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [FTT Contest!]

[Patch.]

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... VGBC4qrLbw

Unfair to you.
Your rat is a September List pet.

Fair?

Unfair to you.

[Aperture Science]

Fair?

Unfair to you.

Thank you~ What should they add to make it fair?

[chiamia]

Pink Balloon + ? = Joker

demand+raritywise c:

[Chrissy]

Unfair to you, but ask for second opinion.

no, it's unfair to top, the shadow creatures are worth a 10 uncommon and so are the collars.[/quote]
Ok, so all together the shadow creatures would equal a 10 uncommon?

And this one?[/quote]


Unfair to them. The Target dog is on the September List.[/quote]
Actually, the trade is fair. x3 The target dog is worth two mid advents. c: Since I am offering the target dog, I'd like some backup on this.

[Aperture Science]

Fair?

Unfair to you.

Thank you~ What should they add to make it fair?

[Patch.]

Unfair to you, but ask for second opinion.

no, it's unfair to top, the shadow creatures are worth a 10 uncommon and so are the collars.

Ok, so all together the shadow creatures would equal a 10 uncommon?

And this one?[/quote]


Unfair to them. The Target dog is on the September List.[/quote]
Actually, the trade is fair. x3 The target dog is worth two mid advents. c: Since I am offering the target dog, I'd like some backup on this.[/quote]

Yes, the trade is fair, but since you are part of the trade, you really shouldn't be giving an opinion.

[Veja]

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... VGBC4qrLbw

Unfair to you.
Your rat is a September List pet.

Thank you. c: What should be added?

[Chrissy]

Unfair to you, but ask for second opinion.

no, it's unfair to top, the shadow creatures are worth a 10 uncommon and so are the collars.

Ok, so all together the shadow creatures would equal a 10 uncommon?

And this one?

Unfair to them. The Target dog is on the September List.[/quote]
Actually, the trade is fair. x3 The target dog is worth two mid advents. c: Since I am offering the target dog, I'd like some backup on this.[/quote]

Yes, the trade is fair, but since you are part of the trade, you really shouldn't be giving an opinion.

[/quote]
Excuse me? I know my rarities. I shouldn't give an opinion just because I'm part of a trade?

[♥Sterek♥]

Unfair to you, but ask for second opinion.

no, it's unfair to top, the shadow creatures are worth a 10 uncommon and so are the collars.

Ok, so all together the shadow creatures would equal a 10 uncommon?

And this one?[/quote]


Unfair to them. The Target dog is on the September List.[/quote]
Actually, the trade is fair. x3 The target dog is worth two mid advents. c: Since I am offering the target dog, I'd like some backup on this.[/quote]

Yes, the trade is fair, but since you are part of the trade, you really shouldn't be giving an opinion.

[/quote]

she can give her opinion, even if she is in the trade. I would say it's a little unfair to the target since it has good demand and 2 mid avdents are worth a grinner and the target is 1 place above it.

[DaDwarf]

Unfair to you, but ask for second opinion.

no, it's unfair to top, the shadow creatures are worth a 10 uncommon and so are the collars.

Ok, so all together the shadow creatures would equal a 10 uncommon?

And this one?[/quote]


Unfair to them. The Target dog is on the September List.[/quote]
Actually, the trade is fair. x3 The target dog is worth two mid advents. c: Since I am offering the target dog, I'd like some backup on this.[/quote]

Yes, the trade is fair, but since you are part of the trade, you really shouldn't be giving an opinion.

Excuse me? I know my rarities. I shouldn't give an opinion just because I'm part of a trade?

Seeing that incorrect advice was given, i think Reason only posted to make sure it was corrected. The target dog is technically worth 2 mid-advents and a bit.