The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [FTT Contest!]

[lucifer morningstar]

is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 9fcPPXXXbg
thank you in advance c:

Not fair to you at all.

Demand wise, unfair to you. Rarity wise, looks alright.

[Celozon]

Fair?
If not, what could be changed?

Unfair to you, take out 2 of the 2011 common owls.

is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 9fcPPXXXbg
thank you in advance c:

Not fair to you at all. :)

thank you c:
what could be changed, if you don't mind my asking?

I don't know what its currently going for, but I got over 2 2009 rares for mine when I had it. I suggest adding at least a 2010 rare. The green bat dog tends to be pretty popular.

Is this considered fair? C:

The first two pets are on my wishlist, this is on Demand and on Date.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... c8wcW8ZoEA

Looks about fair to me demand-wise.

[melody.]

{noleah, if you just want to message me what you want for your 5C$ for helping me? c:}

I thought I saw somewhere a trade with this pet

With a bottom tier advent list pet, and it was supposed to have been fair. Is this true?
{2008 rare}
Thanks C:

[gizmo,]

is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 9fcPPXXXbg
thank you in advance c:

thank you c:
what could be changed, if you don't mind my asking?

Whoops. Sorry! Didn't look at the date or Rare's list.
I'd say that's pretty fair unless it is a rerelease from a later year

thank you for your help c:
i've had some people tell me the dog, the green one, is a rerelease from like 09 or something, though i'm not sure.

[lucifer morningstar]

{noleah, if you just want to message me what you want for your 5C$ for helping me? c:}

I thought I saw somewhere a trade with this pet

With a bottom tier advent list pet, and it was supposed to have been fair. Is this true?
{2008 rare}
Thanks C:

False, this dog is not on the advent list.

gizmo, it's a rerelease from 2oo8. ;]

[melody.]

{noleah, if you just want to message me what you want for your 5C$ for helping me? c:}

I thought I saw somewhere a trade with this pet

With a bottom tier advent list pet, and it was supposed to have been fair. Is this true?
{2008 rare}
Thanks C:

False, this dog is not on the advent list.

Thankyou ^^

[gizmo,]

{noleah, if you just want to message me what you want for your 5C$ for helping me? c:}

I thought I saw somewhere a trade with this pet

With a bottom tier advent list pet, and it was supposed to have been fair. Is this true?
{2008 rare}
Thanks C:

False, this dog is not on the advent list.

gizmo, it's a rerelease from 2oo8. ;]

thank you! c:
so what does that mean for this trade? is it fair or no?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 9fcPPXXXbg

[Celozon]

is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 9fcPPXXXbg
thank you in advance c:
what could be changed, if you don't mind my asking?

Whoops. Sorry! Didn't look at the date or Rare's list.
I'd say that's pretty fair unless it is a rerelease from a later year :)

thank you for your help c:
i've had some people tell me the dog, the green one, is a rerelease from like 09 or something, though i'm not sure.

It was originally released in 2008 but if memory serves me correctly it was also available through 2009.

{noleah, if you just want to message me what you want for your 5C$ for helping me? c:}

I thought I saw somewhere a trade with this pet

With a bottom tier advent list pet, and it was supposed to have been fair. Is this true?
{2008 rare}
Thanks C:

No it would be unfair to the advent. Green bat dog does have good popularity and is worth more than normal, but not as much as a low advent.

(Oh what? lol didn't even notice that, its fine, I'm just happy to help out ^.^ )

thank you! c:
so what does that mean for this trade? is it fair or no?

Low advent for green bat dog is unfair to the advent, 2009 rare + 2010 rare is fair rarity-wise but unfair to you demand-wise.

[gizmo,]

thank you noleah and anyone else who helped me. i really appreciated it! <3

[GrumpyCinnamonster]

I don't think this is fair, but it's quantity, so it's really confusing. Advice? Thank you.