The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[supercrown]

Add...... more?

[Slushie~♫]

Okay I REALLY want the new store set so badly am even thinking of offering my watermelon doggie since am having a hardtime. I did finally found a set for trade buuuuuut...I wonder if the second offer would work better? >:
Offer that I was going to make:
or
Other offer:


(Also both of what am offering is on the person's wishlist)

[Mara.]

Galaxy Bunny for Apple?

[Dee & Faulk]

Galaxy Bunny for Apple?

Unfair for the apple.

[WilliamStripes]

rare pink and purple 08 tess horse for 08 rare royal dog?

[Seasonal]

rare pink and purple 08 tess horse for 08 rare royal dog?

If you're talking about the Horse from the Advent Calendar, then it is unfair to the Horse. If not, I have no idea which Horse you're talking about.

Edit - is this the horse that you are talking about?

[dramaqueenliness]

Is this fair?

Their offer:


..for my trade pets:

[BrightPink]

Is this offer fair for a vixen advent?

[Seasonal]

Is this offer fair for a vixen advent?

The '08 Dog? If so, unfair to the Vixen.

[~Rachy~]

Is this fair? If not, which side should add what? thanks



for