The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [FTT Contest!]

[Kyar]

UR B-Wolf for sunback? Factoring demand in too :3

Unfair to the BW, even factoring demand.

I disagree, it's unfair to Sunback due to demand.

The most I've ever seen a sunback go for is a dogtag.
Unfair to the BW. :)

[lucifer morningstar]

Anyone have an opinion in this one?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... a1S0ysjReA

[Solloby]

Guys guys guys... the Rares List Guide already factors in demand!
A Dark leopard dog is worth a Dark leopard dog.
An UR BFW is worth an UR BFW.
Don't go applying demand twice D:

The only pets you really need to watch out for are Joker and BA, because they are funny pets that everyone pays quadruple for regardless of what they are listed as, so with them it's really just a case of "if you have one put it up for auction, if you want one find someone who will take a fair trade or small overpay".

With low demand rares list pets like UR Mint and the Heart Speckled Rats, they are still worth their value, but just avoid them if you only want them to trade on unless you are prepared to do a bit of searching for someone who wants them to keep. Once you find someone that wants them, you're good to go, it's likely they'll pay fair because those pets are pretty rare and that's why they are listed so high.

[undertaker.]

Anyone have an opinion in this one?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... a1S0ysjReA

Slightly unfair to them. I think all of those items together plus the pet are worth about 60C$

[Kyar]

Anyone have an opinion in this one?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... a1S0ysjReA

Looks unfair to them. :) That's 55 C$ and a rare. I'd say about 40 C$ would be plenty. :)

[GoldenRetrieverDogs]

Would this be fair? c:
(trade includes 124 rats)

Not really,
It's because they're trading you at least over 30 OMG SO commons, a few uncommons, and commons just for a rare.

[Bumpy cantelope]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... PbFH6SEJAw

fair?

[lucifer morningstar]

Anyone have an opinion in this one?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... a1S0ysjReA

Slightly unfair to them. I think all of those items together plus the pet are worth about 60C$

Thanks. Another opinion would be appreciated. :]

[galaxy.]

Thanks guys C: I'll take that into account <3

[quittingforgood.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=23637618&userid=173220&signature=LO6zfPhUkqkyPbFH6SEJAw

fair?

I really do not mean to be rude, but this is in NO WAYS AT ALL fair. First of all, the bunny is not even worth the FIRST one on the list. The bunny is a very rare from '11. The wolf is a very rare from '08 when CS FIRST opened. AND THEN you have at LEAST three '10 very rares. This trade is in NO WAYS fair.