The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [FTT Contest!]

[siilence]

so, I'm holding a Raven Dog auction, and I was just wondering if I could get some help determining the value of these bids? c:
One
Two
Three
Currently I'm liking Bid Three the most, however I would still very much appreciate some help in determining which is most fair. ^-^
Any help would be greatly appreciated. c:

Bid one is overpaying the most, with the September and advent list pet ^^

I didn't think Bid One had a September..? There's the Grown White Scarf Dog, and the Candy Cane Bwolf, which are both Advents..unless I'm just getting confused? x3; //slapped

Haha xD sorry!
I thought the pup was the PPS ;D
But yes, bid three is the best ^^

[Tea.Time]

this one Fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... KdgnmPV0dw

thanks in advance~

[Stripes.]

Grey Border Collie for this group

I'm pretty sure it's fair according to the rares list but I'm not exactly sure about demand.
Any help would be greatly appreciated! <3

[cheeryarver]

Haha xD sorry!
I thought the pup was the PPS ;D
But yes, bid three is the best ^^

Ah! I can see why you thought that haha xD
Thank you for your help~ ^-^

[♥Sterek♥]

Grey Border Collie for this group

I'm pretty sure it's fair according to the rares list but I'm not exactly sure about demand.
Any help would be greatly appreciated! <3

It's overpay for the grey border collie, even with demand.

[Stripes.]

Grey Border Collie for this group

I'm pretty sure it's fair according to the rares list but I'm not exactly sure about demand.
Any help would be greatly appreciated! <3

It's overpay for the grey border collie, even with demand.

Thank you! I'll make sure to let the other user know it isn't fair to them. <33

[Tea.Time]

this one Fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... KdgnmPV0dw

thanks in advance~

[Weiss Schnee]

Would a Pink Sorbet be enough for a UR Malk?
I was told the demand for the Sorb is bad ;-;

[OceanBlast]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... fXkGX1CzuQ

Is this fair?

[cookies.]

this one Fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... KdgnmPV0dw

thanks in advance~

I would say fair to you. But try to get another opinion as I don't know about these old pets ALOT. c: