The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [FTT Contest!]

[~illbewaiting]

wouldTHIS be a fair trade for my rose dog? my trading partner said that the rat was on the rares list

no, the rat is a september and the rose pps in on the main list

it's not the PPS it's the adult version

But rats have lower demand than dogs. Unfair to you.

[Dragon Documentary]

wouldTHIS be a fair trade for my rose dog? my trading partner said that the rat was on the rares list

no, the rat is a september and the rose pps in on the main list

mine is going to be a rose dog though, not a PPS :c

[light.]

Would the Blue Sorbet Bun be fair to the CEG Bun, demand-wise?

thank you bravery c: could i get a second opinion please?

[Dragon Documentary]

But rats have lower demand than dogs. Unfair to you.

kk thanks!!

[KayAuss]

How unfair is this? It's a bid for an auction but I really don't want to post if if its ridiculous http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ASB1nEHraw

[Syberia]

What would I need to add with a sunback to make it fair for an UR BW?

[Cisarena]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... LvK6I2tFHg

Is this fair rarity and demand wise?

[light.]

Would the Blue Sorbet Bun be fair to the CEG Bun, demand-wise?

thank you bravery c: could i get a second opinion please?

[♥Sterek♥]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=23468999&userid=359479&signature=RwIFL2_IOa_aLvK6I2tFHg

Is this fair rarity and demand wise?

Unfair to top.

[Etruuco]

The Spiderwing is one of my dreamies, but I don't know how much I'd be overpaying if I accepted this. How much would need to be added to their side to make this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... pV0_2J5ZCg

Also, for my Speckled Rat auction, how would you compare Bid 3 to Bids 1 and 2? I know that's the UR Purple Horse, and it's right below the rat, but how is the demand for it too?
Bid 1
Bid 2
Bid 3

For the first one quite a bit would need to be added to their side. For the rat, bid #3 is worth the most because of the UR tess horse.

Thank you! About how much would need to be added to the spiderwing side?

And what is the difference (as in, if you could subtract trades, what would be the remainder) between the bid with the Tess horse compared to the first bid?

And a side question, how is demand for that horse?