The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [FTT Contest!]

[piper.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=23438447&userid=364407&signature=5O-PqNYId-61_CXuIm-oGw
Is this fair? Thank you in advance!

Unfair to the 09' dog.

[typewriter,]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=23426998&userid=85654&signature=7l1qyQ5EJf_oElSa_TRXpw Is this fair?

Very unfair to you. They need to add about three mid advents or scarf PPS.

[HeartBeat]

What would I need to add to a Pink September for a Sunjewel Bunny? Thank you for any help

[niceplant]

.
.
.
I had previously offered significant overpay, they cancelled but have now offered this PeaPS. I want to take out the grown 2010 rare and replace it with another uncommon (either 2010 or 2009) since I'm offering that mosaic PPS that has also has been difficult to obtain.

what do you think?

It'd be fair just to swap one of the '10 rares for the one of her side.

[~Arerona~]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=23426998&userid=85654&signature=7l1qyQ5EJf_oElSa_TRXpw Is this fair?

unfair to you

Thanks

How much should be added?

[Grace & Ria]

How many nons is a Sunjewel worth?

Or what needs to be added to a Sunjewel for a UR Tigerdog?

And also, how many September list pets could I get with my Pink Balloon dog?

Sorry for all the questions, I've never owned these pets before o.O

A sunjewel is 5 nons. Technically sunjewel and the tiger can be a straight swap, people general add at least a couple high rares lists below the gap or possibly something above the gap to the sunjewel.
Depends on the september pets.

Say, mid-high septembers? How many of each?

[typewriter,]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=23426998&userid=85654&signature=7l1qyQ5EJf_oElSa_TRXpw Is this fair?

unfair to you

Thanks

How much should be added?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=23426998&userid=85654&signature=7l1qyQ5EJf_oElSa_TRXpw Is this fair?

Very unfair to you. They need to add about three mid advents or scarf PPS.

[lana del rey]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=23438446&userid=299275&signature=gegZZUFB8BUmmCs6gV1nNQ

depends on where the ur dog is on the list.

[christine,]

Does a blue rose equal a red rose?

[Ara.]

Does a blue rose equal a red rose?

No. The Blue Rose is higher on the September List by a few tiers.

The September List
(note that there is a notable gap in worth between these pets and the July/Augusts)
click for pictured list
Dark Leopard = Black Advent
Grey Dragon = Devil/Blood PPS = Blue Ice Rat
Blue Rose = Red-X = Angel Advent
Purple Batdog
Lime Ice Rat
Cake Dogs*** = White Dragon =Dark Pawprint Rat = Dark Heart Rat = Skull Rat
Flop-eared Pink September = Palomino Tess Horse
Red Rose = BMD = Sunjewel Bunny = Light Pawprint Rat = Light Heart Rat = Flower/Toxic Rat
Pink Striped September = Pink Patchy September = Winged Blood Dog
Scarf PPS
Target Dog
Light Leopard = Grinner [s] = Halloween Cat = Skelebun
Red Dragon = Drink Me = Red Cerberus

* italics = not from September '08 but equivalent in value.