The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [FTT Contest!]

[Quitting~]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Y9oC-AihnQ
fair my '09 rares? If not what needs to added?

I'd say unfair to you.

any second opinions? and still wondering what needs to be added on what side?

[Sunshine1515]

For Blue Rose compared to For Blue Rose

I got an opinion that the Target bid was better, but the first bid is a re-re-added to bid [:

[Umbrellas]

For Blue Rose compared to For Blue Rose

I got an opinion that the Target bid was better, but the first bid is a re-re-added to bid [:

Even taking rereleases into account, the target dog one looks better to me

[WhiteWolfVision]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=23404349&userid=67830&signature=QIOY-9SdQnkJPWPts4b12A

fair? thank you very much! <3

unfair to them

thank you! =))

[Unicowrn]

All five toxics for a dogtag?

Would realllly appreciate an answer as I may auto this on the dogtag auction

[heaven.]

i dont think this is fair but you tell me if you think it is... http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... MpU4kB0H5w

[Ashara]

What needs to be added to make this fair(the pup will grow to be a rose PPS)?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... W28vVmXYxQ

[/quote][/quote][/quote][/quote]

[Umbrellas]

All five toxics for a dogtag?

Would realllly appreciate an answer as I may auto this on the dogtag auction

I'm currently on my phone so I have no access to my rarity notes or the list but I'm pretty sure this s unfair to the dogtag. I know the Sunback is worth four Sorbs/toxics and I'm pretty sure dogtags go for at least two nons and that would be six toxics. So yeah unfair to the dogtag:)

[elder price]

fair demand-wise? The pup is going to turn into the devil PPS. ^^

[Time Lord Cassie]

Is this fair? ^^
If not, what should be added/removed?
Not my trade, but my friend wants to know.