The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [FTT Contest!]

[Qualeo]

Fair? If not, what would need ot be added?

[angelginger]

is this fair

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... FOQtAOVm4Q

[♥Sterek♥]

Is this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... jI06pNtv0g

Thanks for any answers =)

I say unfair to top, thats a really good offer, since they are going to be around a red toxxic

Okay, thanks a lot.
Do you think also that the cat is going to be on the Rares List, but with a low demand, like the UR Banana?

Its defenetly goig on the rare list, atm most people say around red toxic level. Maby the demand will rise, but I dont think so

[Violenca]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 8BRo_2p_dg

what have to be added to make it fair ?

[~Smiley~Doggy~]

Fair demand wise?

I have seen chechires go for more but that trade is great.

@ darkstar~ yup.

Really?!?! I got my Cheshire for 1 uncommon

[Lively..]

Fair demand wise?

I have seen chechires go for more but that trade is great.

@ darkstar~ yup.

Really?!?! I got my Cheshire for 1 uncommon

Oh. That's underpay. 2012 store pets go for early 2010 rares.

[Qualeo]

is this fair

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... FOQtAOVm4Q

Very unfair to the Dark Shima BW (Bottom BW). It's a main list pet. (I'm fairly certain the rat doesn't gro win to a list pet Might be wrong on that)

[Linja]

Is this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... jI06pNtv0g

Thanks for any answers =)

I say unfair to top, thats a really good offer, since they are going to be around a red toxxic

Okay, thanks a lot.
Do you think also that the cat is going to be on the Rares List, but with a low demand, like the UR Banana?

Its defenetly goig on the rare list, atm most people say around red toxic level. Maby the demand will rise, but I dont think so

Then, you would accept it?

[maliy]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... jBsUKj2_dg
What should they add? O.o

[Celozon]

Fair? If not, what would need ot be added?

Unfair to you. I think add a low main list or high september to thier side but get a second opinion on exactly what to add.

is this fair

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... FOQtAOVm4Q

Unfair to you.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=23222974&userid=265048&signature=z3B_T7izBEYm8BRo_2p_dg

what have to be added to make it fair ?

Added a couple more 2009 rare to thier side, though it would depend on exact date and popularity.

I am looking to overpay in both the trades, but i dont want to get ripped off completely (especially in the second trade). I need a more advanced answer for the first one and any opinions for the second please!

#1; http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Cg_EAsoVFw
First, I would like to make sure I am Overpaying, second, is it a fair enough overpay to them?

#2; http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... q_xwUMgAdA
Do you think that I should change my dog to a younger rare or should I accept it as is?

First unfair to them (I think, can't remember what the b-wolf and pup grow into though) but even if they turn out rare rats don't have much demand so probably still unfair to them.
Second unfair to you.

Opps! I forgot they are re releases!
The BW will be a VR from 09 and the dog a 10 rare or uncommon, How much more do you think I should add to make it overpay?

If you want to make sure your the one overpaying than that should be fine. The b-wolf being very rare would make it overpay.