The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[Missillinois93]

What would be a fair trade in this situation?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... d=22702669

[Crazychick3000]

Is this fair? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=22703047&userid=333254&signature=91IHmiUNYGF6erX2pBcfEA

REALLY UNFAIR to them; you want some of their rares list pets while your only offering an advents plus two other pets. At LEAST two-three mid-advents and 1-3 low rares list pets need to be added to make it fair.

Isn't the winged wood angel a rare list pet?

[lucifer morningstar]

Is this fair? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=22703047&userid=333254&signature=91IHmiUNYGF6erX2pBcfEA

REALLY UNFAIR to them; you want some of their rares list pets while your only offering an advents plus two other pets. At LEAST two-three mid-advents and 1-3 low rares list pets need to be added to make it fair.

The winged wood dog they're offering is on the Main List. Did you realize that?

What would be a fair trade in this situation?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... d=22702669

Wrong link. ;]

[Umbrellas]

Is this fair? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=22703047&userid=333254&signature=91IHmiUNYGF6erX2pBcfEA

REALLY UNFAIR to them; you want some of their rares list pets while your only offering an advents plus two other pets. At LEAST two-three mid-advents and 1-3 low rares list pets need to be added to make it fair.

it is unfair to them, but you realize that the "advent" on the bottom is really the Winged Wood Angel and worth a Balloon Dog?
Something around a Skeleton PPS should be added to the bottom.
please don't give false advice ^^

[Z4XX0N]

Is this fair? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=22703047&userid=333254&signature=91IHmiUNYGF6erX2pBcfEA

REALLY UNFAIR to them; you want some of their rares list pets while your only offering an advents plus two other pets. At LEAST two-three mid-advents and 1-3 low rares list pets need to be added to make it fair.

uh, that pet is on the main list.
But it's unfair to them c:

[.:StitchLover:.]

Is this fair? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=22703047&userid=333254&signature=91IHmiUNYGF6erX2pBcfEA

REALLY UNFAIR to them; you want some of their rares list pets while your only offering an advents plus two other pets. At LEAST two-three mid-advents and 1-3 low rares list pets need to be added to make it fair.

it is unfair to them, but you realize that the "advent" on the bottom is really the Winged Wood Angel and worth a Balloon Dog?
Something around a Skeleton PPS should be added to the bottom.
please don't give false advice ^^

sorry, I thought I copied a different trade; I'll delete the other one

[Crazychick3000]

What should be removed from the top to make it fair? I'm confused by the advice since the Winged Wood Angel is a higher on The Rare's List.

[.:StitchLover:.]

What should be removed from the top to make it fair? I'm confused by the advice since the Winged Wood Angel is a higher on The Rare's List.

Sorry, copied the wrong trade. Ignore my advice. Maybe add another 09 rare

[Umbrellas]

What should be removed from the top to make it fair? I'm confused by the advice since the Winged Wood Angel is a higher on The Rare's List.

The pets on the other person's side add up to more than a Nonballoon ^^

What should be removed from the top to make it fair? I'm confused by the advice since the Winged Wood Angel is a higher on The Rare's List.

Sorry, copied the wrong trade. Ignore my advice. Maybe add another 09 rare

?? Obviously you don't know your rarities
The top should add a lot more than an '09 rare
Something around a Skeleton PPS should be added

[Celeritas~]

How fair is this trade?
Thanks in advance!