The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[Zaivinx]

Is this a fair trade? If not, any advice on how it could be balanced? Thank you for your time!

[Patch.]

fair? n_n

Personally I wouldn't take that ^^ (and not cause the cerb is my dreamie, I know my rarities )

okay, any other opinions? c:

I'd say unfair to the Cerberus.

[Not me nope]

D:

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... cbvtf7CyRg
Is this not a 09 very rare BW...? Seeing as it looks like they're overpaying by quite a bit, it makes me wonder...

[Stolen Secrets]

Would this offer be a wise trade-up and good move? or am I better off with the Advents && apple?

Please, please, please only give advice if you are sure. This is a big deal for me.

Thank you.

-A u t u m e l

I would keep your pets personally, you are overpaying for that september list pet in my opinion ^^ But get another opinion <3

[Redwaller]

I'm rather certain that since the rare is not on my wishlist, and is also from this year, that there are too many pets on my end that are too old. I'm not sure how it would be fair to pair it down, however, and would like help in doing so. I appreciate the help and advice, and thank you for your time.
The Trade

Unfair to bottom

Thank you for the quick response. In regards to my post, what would be the best way to make the trade fair, do you think?

EDIT: Thank you all the same, but the trade was cancelled.

[&& echo;]

fair? n_n

I'd say unfair to the Cerberus.

Agreed.

[Stolen Secrets]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=22325219&userid=358219&signature=vwDIwaSuqGYtlIyjbQz7cw

Fair? Demand and rarity wise?

[niceplant]

fair? n_n

I'd say unfair to the Cerberus.

how many more rares should they add?

[&& echo;]

Would this offer be a wise trade-up and good move? or am I better off with the Advents && apple?

Please, please, please only give advice if you are sure. This is a big deal for me.

Thank you.

-A u t u m e l

[siilence]

Would this offer be a wise trade-up and good move? or am I better off with the Advents && apple?

Please, please, please only give advice if you are sure. This is a big deal for me.

Thank you.

-A u t u m e l

I would keep your pets personally, you are overpaying for that september list pet in my opinion ^^ But get another opinion <3

I would definitely take it, they are overpaying, and UR apples tend to go for a lot less due to demand anyway.