The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[Tricksters]

Alright thanks!

[~Remember~]

Is this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 7Qw0ymJHqA


Thanks in advance!

[quietude]

Would trading a Vixen advent for a Hollyfox Dog be fair? They're on the same tier so it should be, right?

help?

I'd say yes. Though get another opinion.

[quietude]

Is this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 7Qw0ymJHqA


Thanks in advance!

Unfair to the person who is giving the Nick.

[Fat Unicorn]

Would trading a Vixen advent for a Hollyfox Dog be fair? They're on the same tier so it should be, right?

help?

I've answered this. ;3

Fair?

Fair?

If I need to add to their side/my side, please include that information.
Thank you ^-^

1. Unfair to them (Add 1 mid advent + 5-6 2009 rares to your side).
2. Unfair to them (Add 1 mid advent + 3 2009 rares to your side). ^^

[~Remember~]

OK thanks


(The person offering the nick was me)

[Centri]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... VKZTNOtLJg

Is the gap between the Noncoon, Nontag, Nonswirl and the Nonjewel equal to a green sorbet?

No, it would be less than a sorbet. Probably closer to a non-balloon or so. Get another opinion.

Thank you. Anyone else have an opinion on this offer?[/quote]

Unfair to you - a noncoon/tag/swirl is worth 3 sorbets, and you only have to add a mid sep to jump the gap up to Nonjewel.[/quote]

Ok, thank you
I will put the Nonswirl for Pink+Blue+Yellow as a better offer than this one, then. Would a sunback be a reasonable auto in this auction, or is the demand for that crazy-high?

[Fat Unicorn]

Ok, thank you
I will put the Nonswirl for Pink+Blue+Yellow as a better offer than this one, then. Would a sunback be a reasonable auto in this auction, or is the demand for that crazy-high?

Um.. No, a Sunback wouldn't be a reasonable auto. ^^;

[.:StitchLover:.]

Is this fair in return for 221 2012 staff pups?

[Centri]

Ok, thank you
I will put the Nonswirl for Pink+Blue+Yellow as a better offer than this one, then. Would a sunback be a reasonable auto in this auction, or is the demand for that crazy-high?

Um.. No, a Sunback wouldn't be a reasonable auto. ^^;

Ok, I thought it might be, since it is one step above the nonjewel, but I suppose the steps are bigger further up the rares list. Thanks again