The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[Silverstar]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... k4VuQCyiRg

Fair?

It's actually unfair to them, I'm unsure about demand. ^^;

[ïṉкɾєαℓṃ]

how much are they overpaying here? ^-^;
thank-you for checking and any help, it's very appreciated,, ^-^;; <3 <3

they are overpaying by a mid-late 09 rare or so

nyah, thank-you ^-^;



EDIT:

Is this a bit better? I applogize for the bother but I don't usually trade for 09's ><
I really appreciate it,,, ^x^;;;;

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=21888362&userid=172508&signature=VEPN8kukTslQrHDqUNa47Q
Fair to Pink striped sept & Red Rose?

unfair to the rose side.

Fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... KJk27vX1RA
Thank you! :)

Very unfair to you. Their side doesn't even add up to your '08 vr dog. Those 2012 Halloween pets do have demand but they are expect way too much.

Would by chance this VR Bun be equal for one of these January '09 Rares?

Unfair to the bunny.

THAT BUNNY IS ON THE ADVENT LIST!!! both trades are unfair to the bun.

do not use caps, or give false information. the bunny is not on the list.
even if it was, the first would be unfair to the bottom still. but since its not, its very unfair to the bottom.
the second is unfair to the bun still, just slightly

Thank you ^^..

How about now?

Sorry to keep poking.. ^^;;

unfair to you by around a nonballoon - green toxic

[ericarawrr]

Would by chance this VR Bun be equal for one of these January '09 Rares?

Unfair to the bunny.

[/quote]

What would make it fair? Does anyone know?

[Kyar]

Does anyone know if this is fair? Thank you!

[PhoenixRising]

What should they add to make this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... aGJzlTOurg

[Umbrellas]

Would by chance this VR Bun be equal for one of these January '09 Rares?

Unfair to the bunny.

What would make it fair? Does anyone know?[/quote]

Probably another early/mid '09 rare.

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

Would by chance this VR Bun be equal for one of these January '09 Rares?

What would make it fair? Does anyone know?

Probably another early/mid '09 rare.

I would say a late 09 rare. not an early or mid

[Silverstar]

Thank you ^^..

How about now?

Sorry to keep poking.. ^^;;

Agreed with tru; unfair to you.

[ScuroFenice]

Fair at all? Wondering about the demand of the warrior cat but I know the wolf pack pets also have demand:

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=21887569&userid=247513&signature=oNTMI1xAIDN24dF2V9R7_A

Unfair to the wolf dog by 3 month rule and demand. And that's not a warrior cat. c: It's just a sitting snow cat. The warrior cats actually look like real cats.

it was in the warrior cat position so I thought it was >.< sorry my bad and thanks, they sent the trade