The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[Fat Unicorn]

Of the two trades below, which one is fairer Demand and Rarity wise? Also, are they fair for the dogtag? If not, by much? c:

• Trade One •
• Trade Two •

The first one is unfair to you technically, but demandwise you'll be better off with the Sunback. :3 And the Grinner + rats in that trade will be a pain to trade off, although everything else is fine.

For the second trade, it's unfair to them technically, but demandwise you're better off with the dogtag by a long shot. UR bananas, rats, and UR horses are amongst the hardest rares list pets to trade, so it wouldn't be a wise move. D:

[Grace & Ria]

Of the two trades below, which one is fairer Demand and Rarity wise? Also, are they fair for the dogtag? If not, by much? c:

• Trade One •
• Trade Two •

The first one is unfair to you technically, but demandwise you'll be better off with the Sunback. :3 And the Grinner + rats in that trade will be a pain to trade off, although everything else is fine.

For the second trade, it's unfair to them technically, but demandwise you're better off with the dogtag by a long shot. UR bananas, rats, and UR horses are amongst the hardest rares list pets to trade, so it wouldn't be a wise move. D:

So personally, would you take either of them? What could the Sunback go for? (I'm trying to move up the list to a Moonswirl level at the moment. )

The first trade has been auto cancelled by the Grinner beign traded, so we were going to substitute it for their Eat Me possibly if we were to resend it? c:

[Fat Unicorn]

Of the two trades below, which one is fairer Demand and Rarity wise? Also, are they fair for the dogtag? If not, by much? c:

• Trade One •
• Trade Two •

The first one is unfair to you technically, but demandwise you'll be better off with the Sunback. :3 And the Grinner + rats in that trade will be a pain to trade off, although everything else is fine.

For the second trade, it's unfair to them technically, but demandwise you're better off with the dogtag by a long shot. UR bananas, rats, and UR horses are amongst the hardest rares list pets to trade, so it wouldn't be a wise move. D:

So personally, would you take either of them? What could the Sunback go for? (I'm trying to move up the list to a Moonswirl level at the moment. )

The first trade has been auto cancelled by the Grinner beign traded, so we were going to substitute it for their Eat Me possibly if we were to resend it? c:

No, I wouldn't. I know of someone who recently trading a Sunback + a little bit for a Moonswirl, although that was a one in a million shot. xP

[Catheren]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... VroxRDHhZA

Please spare me the "it's an 09 VR!" statment (it gets a little repetative, no offence XD) I know it's an 09 VR- but there are 93 pets and 20 items in this trade, and the dart frog BW isn't on the rares list- I checked. So I'm not sure what to make of the trade.

[sakura flower]

Is that fair? Thank you

and

this?

[Fat Unicorn]

Is that fair? Thank you

and

this?

Both are unfair to them technically. ^^

[Catheren]

Is that fair? Thank you

and

this?

I'd say the first is unfair to them, the Pumkin dog doesn't really have that much demand, and the scythe bat gove overshadowed by the wish and pumpkin bat, but I don't think the pumpkin has that much demand alone.

The second I think unfair to you, there's a lot of demand on the glow dog last I saw was pretty high. I got mine for a 11 common though, so you could do worse ^w^

[sakura flower]

thank you

[phoebe11850]

Is this fair?

[Kiinotasha]

Is this fair? I'm still really bad on how much sore pets are worth compared to other pets. Thank you to anyone that helps