The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

What must be added here, to would make it fair?

Probably a 2008 advent

please dont give advice such as "probably." not to mention an 08 advent wont do. much more than an advent is needed.
a september just below the BA on the list needs to be added. not counting demand

[c h r i s t m a s]

Is this fair?
I really stink at cross year trades, as you can tell...

i would say unfair to you, the woodwing, because of the demand in the RBM

Thanks
What would make it fair?
And do you know about the first one?
I was just told the Null PPS was worth a few o9's, so I don't know what exactly that meant.....

i'm not sure what would make it fair xD sorry
and the null pps i believe you could get a bit more for it ^^

[Umbrellas]

Is this fair?
I really stink at cross year trades, as you can tell...

Also, need help with this trade, but only from people who know the Rares list well
Click!

1) Unfair to the Null PPS
2) Unfair to you

[CalicoWolf]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... d0xgjxJyQg

Is this fair?

[The PSIentist]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=21599585&userid=331950&signature=JUw5uX-JSJ5e_z1C5d19zA
Is this fair thanks to anyone who answers

[Acxa]

Devil pps = dark leo? OR is it unfair to Devil pps

I know dark leo is one line above it, but is it unfair to it because of leos demand?

[Nari UwU]

Is this fair?
I really stink at cross year trades, as you can tell...

Also, need help with this trade, but only from people who know the Rares list well
Click!

1) Unfair to the Null PPS
2) Unfair to you

About what should be added to the second trade?

[Umbrellas]

Is this fair?
I really stink at cross year trades, as you can tell...

Also, need help with this trade, but only from people who know the Rares list well
Click!

1) Unfair to the Null PPS
2) Unfair to you

About what should be added to the second trade?

Something around a Cake Dog
though I'm not sure I'd take it. you'd be better off with the Winged Wood Angel if you're trying to trade up

[Nari UwU]

Alright, thanks ^^

[Vaal Hazak]

I asked because I want to trade this item:



The item guide says it is worth a late '09 uncommon.
So ... could I try to offer on a Halloween '10 rare? Or would it be unfair?