The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[Meowkitten2323]

What could they add to make it fair?

first of all there is no link

second
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... OrvzhZxauw
fair?

[Efrafa]

Thank you for your advice NightofnewRose! Does anyone else want to offer an opinion?

Do you think this trade is better than what I have, equal, or trading down? I would be getting duplicates, so I am mostly interested in the value of the pets.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... HGl1oDzRrQ

Thank you so much!

[Meowkitten2323]

Thank you for your advice NightofnewRose! Does anyone else want to offer an opinion?

Do you think this trade is better than what I have, equal, or trading down? I would be getting duplicates, so I am mostly interested in the value of the pets.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... HGl1oDzRrQ

Thank you so much!

i'd say unfair to you but thats my opinion so you might want to get a second opinion

[Isilcu]

Are either of these fair?

First Trade
Second Trade

Thank you for any and all help! ^^ It's greatly appreciated!

fot the first one i want to say their overpaying but im NOT entirely sure get another opinion

Thank you! Could I please get a second opinion? ^^

[c h r i s t m a s]

Are either of these fair?

First Trade
Second Trade

Thank you for any and all help! ^^ It's greatly appreciated!

fot the first one i want to say their overpaying but im NOT entirely sure get another opinion

Thank you! Could I please get a second opinion? ^^

for the second one its unfair to the 08 pps ^.^

[Isilcu]

Are either of these fair?

First Trade
Second Trade

Thank you for any and all help! ^^ It's greatly appreciated!

for the second one its unfair to the 08 pps ^.^

Thank you! Though the cat was originally released in july 08... I'm just a little confused.

[c h r i s t m a s]

Are either of these fair?

First Trade
Second Trade

Thank you for any and all help! ^^ It's greatly appreciated!

for the second one its unfair to the 08 pps ^.^

Thank you! Though the cat was originally released in july 08... I'm just a little confused.

im just looking at demand ^.^ correct me if im wrong xD

[Foxtress]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... _-1LBCNWLQ

Could someone tell me if this is fair to them?
I was told that it wasn't.
Any help appreciated. ;o

[Meowkitten2323]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=21538842&userid=365985&signature=3uc9t5rERrz6_-1LBCNWLQ

Could someone tell me if this is fair to them?
I was told that it wasn't.
Any help appreciated. ;o

Unfair to you

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... _8_Lky2xiA
I need some advice is this fair?
(Please only reply if you have expirence with advent and september list trading)

[qhost]

Since I've never really got around to asking -- how much could I get for a complete '08 September dog set (including cake dogs + palomino Tess horse)?



Haven't got a response on the pet worth thread, so posting it here.