The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[tawnypelt3]

With demand, is a desert/orange swirl PPS and a 2009 rare Christmas dog fair for a grey border collie?

The PPS and collie are on the same line of the Rares List, but I want to know that my offer is completely fair with demand before I send it.

[Law]

Is this fair?

Meant to send it as a trade where I am overpaying, but it was edited down.
Just checking to see if I'm losing my grasp of CS rarities >.<

[Autotomy]

With demand, is a desert/orange swirl PPS and a 2009 rare Christmas dog fair for a grey border collie?

The PPS and collie are on the same line of the Rares List, but I want to know that my offer is completely fair with demand before I send it.

With the demand and all, I'd maybe add another rare dog, such as one of the rainbow animal litter to your side. :)

@ Law:
I think you need to add a common or so to your side. :3

[tawnypelt3]

With demand, is a desert/orange swirl PPS and a 2009 rare Christmas dog fair for a grey border collie?

The PPS and collie are on the same line of the Rares List, but I want to know that my offer is completely fair with demand before I send it.

With the demand and all, I'd maybe add another rare dog, such as one of the rainbow animal litter to your side.

@ Law:
I think you need to add a common or so to your side. :3

Thank you, Rdze. However, I disagree on your advice for Law. I'd say it's unfair to Law.

[bear]

I've got a few trades that I'm not sure about and would like some help c:

What needs to be added to their side to be fair?

Bid for my sunback auction - fair?

Thank you c:

[Law]

Thanks Rdze and tawnypelt3 :)

Another opinion on this trade?

[aystabre]

Is this a fair trade? Thanks c:

[Autotomy]

@ Tawnypelt3:
I'm not too good with anything below rare, so sorry about that >.<

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=20712227&userid=246427&signature=zKtvFXq3CDxjRq6dxvY0lQ

Fair?

Oh or this?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=20712261&userid=246427&signature=vdU-tjOC11Ap40Zso7blCA

I'd say either is overpay on the top, but demand-wise, I'm not sure. Tokens also seem to be in high-demand right now.

@ thin paper:
I believe so. Get two opinions, however ^^

[Lively..]

Is this fair? I have no clue about items! >.< Thank you!

.

[rain_bullet]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=20716035&userid=250028&signature=AFBG6eacknfifeiMS1Pmig
Is this fair? o3o Sent with the message "This is All I Would Bid ll", so I'm not sure why it's a suggestion @_@